Feedback Forum
- This topic has 10,053 replies, 728 voices, and was last updated 5 days, 16 hours ago by
JaimeMartinezVO.
-
CreatorTopic
-
August 7, 2020 at 9:27 am #15468
David Goldberg
Edge Studio StaffHi! Upload your recordings, and get feedback from your peers!
-
This topic was modified 4 years, 10 months ago by
David Goldberg.
-
This topic was modified 4 years, 7 months ago by
David Goldberg.
-
This topic was modified 7 months ago by
David Goldberg.
-
This topic was modified 7 months ago by
David Goldberg.
-
This topic was modified 7 months ago by
David Goldberg.
-
This topic was modified 7 months ago by
David Goldberg.
-
This topic was modified 4 years, 10 months ago by
-
CreatorTopic
-
AuthorReplies
-
April 8, 2021 at 9:20 pm #66025
John Trape
ParticipantHello everyone,
I have recorded the following narration scripts and would very much welcome any and all feedback, particularly regarding pitch.
Best wishes,
John
1. Walgreens – New Team Members
After more than a century in business, we know what makes a great Walgreens team member. It’s the type of person who values change and excitement. The ones who thrive in a fast-paced environment, ready to learn something new every day. Forward-thinkers. Great communicators. Innovators. People with the drive to succeed – not only for themselves, but also for their co-workers, the company as a whole and the communities we serve. We all come from different backgrounds and bring valuable diverse ideas, but a common mission unites us. And we’re looking for students and recent graduates who are up to the challenge.2. The Julia
You’re listening to the actual recording of “the Julia”. A subsonic moan that doesn’t match the sound of any marine creature ever recorded.
Many biologists will tell you it’s a deep-sea distress call.
And when you listen, it’s easy to see why.
The mysterious howling was captured by deep-sea hydrophones off the coast of Cape Adare.
The same place Nasa captured photographs of a huge, unexplained shadow moving through the water.
It may well be a coincidence, but if the Julia really is a distress call from the deep, perhaps it’s time we answered.
Ninety-five per cent of our oceans remain unexplored.
Are we killing what we’ve yet to discover?3. Voice for the City of Toronto
You know that term “We’re all in this together?” Well, it’s true.
While some of us might be working in government and others not, we’re actually all in the same boat. You see, we’re citizens as well.
We all want the same thing. A city that works for everyone. As fast and efficient and as relevant as can be. Thriving, accessible, and inclusive.Attachments:
You must be logged in to view attached files.-
April 9, 2021 at 2:18 pm #66036
jasjol71
ParticipantJohn, great voice and accent for narration. I really liked your read of The Julia. I do not think it was too slow at all. Just right. I also like your inflections.
-
April 10, 2021 at 1:39 pm #66081
John Trape
ParticipantHi jasjol,
Thank you very much for your feedback. I really appreciate the encouragement.
Kind regards,
John
-
-
April 9, 2021 at 2:11 pm #66034
acbattag
ParticipantJohn – I really felt like your pitch and tone were good on all of the reads. Like Kateyln, my feedback would be centered around the pace. The first and last scripts that you have definitely call for a bit faster of a pace to bring more energy into the read. I would work on changing the pace throughout each of these so that there is some differentiation in each of the scripts. Best of luck! Great scripts for your voice!
-
April 10, 2021 at 1:46 pm #66082
John Trape
ParticipantHi acbattag,
Thank you very much for your encouraging feedback. Yes, I wondered about pace as I listened to them following the recording. I am going to go back and experiment a little more with the pace.
Kind regards,
John
-
-
April 9, 2021 at 1:50 pm #66033
katelyndawnvo
ParticipantHi John – I just had time to listen to the first upload.
I think you have a lovely upbeat and energetic tone. Very friendly and welcoming. So if that is what you are going for with your tone, then you did very well. The pace was too slow and made it sound like you were reading. If you vary the pace while you are reading that is something we do naturally in conversation. Also, there were times you added a pause between words within sentences. Note how you speak to friends and family. Normally we don’t pause within sentences. We say “ready to learn something new every day.” not “ready (pause) to learn something new every day.” These are little things that make a big difference in smoothing out a read and sounding more conversational. I hope that feedback is useful! 🙂Nice work! I love your David Attenborough voice!
-
April 10, 2021 at 1:51 pm #66083
John Trape
ParticipantHi Katelyn,
Thank you very much for taking the time to provide such constructive feedback. I know I have this challenge with pace and have to keep working at it. Similarly, pausing within a sentence and trying to sound conversational. So, absolutely, your feedback is just what I needed.
Kind regards,
John
-
-
-
April 8, 2021 at 8:10 pm #66018
Lilbelle1487
ParticipantFirst Homework Assignment is a go! Excited to get feedback and see what I need to work on. This first reel is a Radio Promo, the second is Johnson’s Baby Shampoo. I’d like any feedback that I can. Thanks!
Attachments:
You must be logged in to view attached files.-
April 9, 2021 at 6:24 pm #66064
TimDKietzman
ParticipantFirst of all, you need to invest in a better recording setup. I could barely hear you, but I could make out enough. You had a great tone and tempo in the Radio Promo and I think you hit good words. However, when you were performing the radio station, the time, and the event, you sounded as if you lost your place and picked it up mid-sentence. This in turn lead you to sound lost in what you were trying to express and even sounded like you were trying to remember the event. If you slip up during recording, you must go back to the last comma or period and start over. That makes the script flow better.
The Baby Shampoo on the other hand sounded like you were going all over the place with your overall tone and there were too many pauses. The words you hit were good, but the tone sounded more like a whiny kid begging someone to try their product. I think you ought to find some baby shampoo commercials on YouTube to better understand how they sound and get inspiration. I hope this helps.-
April 11, 2021 at 7:21 pm #66104
Lilbelle1487
ParticipantYes! Thank you. I actually, had some cord interference that I was unaware of until I posted on here. I’ll be posting again soon an update in hopes that the issue is fixed.
As far as my commercials, great feedback. I can definitely hear in myself what you are saying especially in the Johnson’s Baby Shampoo Commercial.
-
-
-
April 8, 2021 at 2:02 pm #66008
Sherry Newell
ParticipantHere’s a couple more narration practices. I’m a sponge 🙂 absorbing as much info as I can. Any feedback welcome!
Attachments:
You must be logged in to view attached files.-
April 10, 2021 at 3:23 pm #66089
danielh04
ParticipantThe first read was great, took me by surprise that I had to re-listen, though I think your voice is definitely suited for those types of scripts. For the second one, however, it felt a little bit too fast which made the information a little bit overwhelming. Even so, both good tones on both of the scripts.
-
April 10, 2021 at 1:08 am #66073
Robert Broussard
ParticipantSherry, very good effort. I really liked the first one. Your voice, pace and tone was well suited for that script. The second was not bad but maybe the pace could have slowed a tad bit and your voice could be a little more relaxed. Hope this may help.
-
April 9, 2021 at 2:22 pm #66037
jasjol71
ParticipantI thought your volume and tone were spot on for the first one in particular. The second read sounded a bit choppy in parts. I had the impression that your were almost over-articulating the syllables in the longer words. I guess if you are shooting for a bit more of a conversational tone you could knock down the formality a degree or two. But great voice!
-
April 8, 2021 at 7:09 pm #66017
katelyndawnvo
ParticipantHey Sherry –
Fragrance: Lovely read! I love how you painted a picture in the first half of the perfume thing. I think at 0:14 there could be a transition. When you read the whole thing in the hushed whisper voice, I started to lose focus. If you can come into a full voice for the last part once you hit “Roseau articulates…” (however you spell that) I think that is a good spot for a transition.
Healthcare: Really nice tone and feel for this. When you got to “something as important as healthcare”, you did “upspeak” on the word “healthcare”. When we use upspeak (which is a super millennial thing to do) it sounds less confident, like we are asking a question or are unsure about what we are saying. So you can just remember to always bring it down at the end. “create a partnership” – pronounce “a” as “ah” in scripts. I’d say always unless asked specifically to pronounce it “a”.
I think you lost it a little bit at the tag – you had me up until this point. When you say “Edna and US healthcare… raising a standard for… and the rest of the tag” The tag is super important so give it its gravity. At this point, you can be feeling very proud of this healthcare company because it’s yours. Either you own it or you work there or else you wouldn’t be talking about it. But center yourself in some pride for it and really sell me on why this is important, good, or why I should care.Really nice work!!
-
-
April 8, 2021 at 1:48 pm #66001
ritadebur
ParticipantHi everyone – here are some more practice recordings for my narration homework. Trying different genres to get a feel for what my voice would be suited to. Any and all feedback welcome. Thank you so much!
Autism Awareness:As a parent, you can’t help but look at your child and dream about what the future holds. But while you’re dreaming, consider this – the odds that your child will be diagnosed with autism are 1 in 88. Knowing the signs of autism and catching it early can make a world of difference. To learn the signs visit autismspeaks.org. Brought to you by Autism Speaks and the Ad Council.
Macarons:
Macarons are one of the most popular but also most challenging desserts to get right. We spent many months and made dozens of batches in the pursuit of trying to find a recipe and some foolproof techniques to help you get it right the first time. A perfect macaron should be chewy on the inside and crispy on the outside. First things first, you want to let the egg whites come to room temperature for at least 30 minutes before you get started. Having the egg whites rest is gonna result in a much fluffier, airier meringue. So, protip, a really easy way to separate your white from your yolks is to use your hands or you can alternate between eggshells. Now we can move on to our dry ingredients.Anaconda
Giant snakes have a reputation of being aggressive. The anaconda measures over 16 feet and weighs 180 pounds. Its mouth is like a clamp and an animal struggling to get free only sets the grip tighter. At the same time it sets its bite, the anaconda loops its powerful coils around its victim and begins to squeeze. The process takes little more than a second, hardly enough time to react.Attachments:
You must be logged in to view attached files.-
April 9, 2021 at 6:29 pm #66065
TimDKietzman
ParticipantYour voice is well-suited for narration. The tone you used for each of these scripts matched very well and the words you hit were magnificent. Tempo was a tad slow though and your pauses were a little overdone. I heard a great deal of mouth noises too and I would look for a way to fix that. All in all, you are on the right track. Well done.
-
April 8, 2021 at 8:18 pm #66021
Lilbelle1487
ParticipantI could honestly listen to you read a book for bedtime stories. Your voice is rather pleasant.
There were times in each segment that it sounded as if you needed air or water. I could hear the movement of your tongue. Then in the macarons read, there were a few words that I felt as if you over emphasized such as chewy and crispy, overall though rather lovely. I rather enjoyed listening to you. -
April 8, 2021 at 4:15 pm #66013
mara_sherman
ParticipantI love your tone and energy on all of the reads, they really match the text. Just a technical thing- the Macaron recording was a little quieter than the other two, so you may want to play with the volume settings on the Macaron recording.
-
April 8, 2021 at 2:11 pm #66011
Sherry Newell
ParticipantI loved it 🙂
There were a couple moments that the pause was just a tad long making that spot seem a little choppy, but overall, I really enjoyed it!
-
-
April 8, 2021 at 1:24 pm #65994
Sherry Newell
ParticipantHi everyone! I’m working on narration homework. I’m still learning the editing part, but any and all comments about the performance are very welcome and appreciated!
Attachments:
You must be logged in to view attached files.-
April 9, 2021 at 2:25 pm #66038
jasjol71
ParticipantI thought your voice is perfectly suited to a script like Advanced Technology, so corporate narration, training. Very pleasant to listen to. I thought the first sentence was perfect. Then it seemed to get a little choppy in the middle and at the very end. Still, a really good read, in my opinion!
-
April 8, 2021 at 1:53 pm #66005
ritadebur
ParticipantHi Sherry – love the first one – is that for an audio book? I like the emotion and pitch variety in it. I could listen to your voice in an audiobook.
For the Advance Technology – I think you dropped off a little bit when you say …”policy and procedures” like there is a period there instead of a comma?
-
April 8, 2021 at 1:59 pm #66007
Sherry Newell
ParticipantAwesome, thank you! I’m not sure exactly what that excerpt is taken from – I just found it in the script library under the Narration tab, haha.
Thanks for the feedback! I will look/listen to that and see how I can make it better 🙂
-
-
-
April 8, 2021 at 11:48 am #65986
Pmag
ParticipantHey Good morning. Jumping back in with this one. Let me know what you think if you have a moment. I look forward to catching up and listening in.
-M
Attachments:
You must be logged in to view attached files.-
April 9, 2021 at 2:27 pm #66039
jasjol71
ParticipantYou voice seems well suited for this kind of commercial. I kept waiting for you do dig in and go even more “tough guy.” I think that would work.
-
April 8, 2021 at 8:21 pm #66022
Lilbelle1487
ParticipantI have to agree with Ritadebur above, it was slow at start, but the energy picked up and it was a great finish. I heard hard finishes with words that end in s, maybe something to work on. Great work though!
-
April 8, 2021 at 12:22 pm #65988
ritadebur
ParticipantGreat read – though in my opinion I felt the energy and range of pitch was a little low to start and then picked up half way through. Finished well.
-
-
April 8, 2021 at 10:58 am #65980
Official81
ParticipantGood Morning ALL! I am recording my DEMO TODAY!!! So nervous and excited. I JUST want to know if I sound conversational on this read. I didn’t perform any edits so I know there are some plosives and things that you might hear but my goal here is to sound conversational. Please let me know if I am acheiving that goal with this read?
Start you child reading in four weeks with Hooked on Phonics. Use Hooked on Phonics about 20 minutes a day, a few times a week, and your child could be reading a bedtime story to you! This unique 3-step system puts phonics instruction together with 50 great books and fun interactive games to give your child a head start in reading. Try Hooked on Phonics today and see why parents rated it the #1 trusted name in teaching kids to read.
Attachments:
You must be logged in to view attached files.-
April 9, 2021 at 2:27 pm #66040
jasjol71
ParticipantBest of luck to you with the demo recording!
-
April 8, 2021 at 1:19 pm #65993
Sherry Newell
ParticipantGood luck on your demo!! I think you did sound pretty conversational, and I think you could even lean into that a little more by really focusing on the specific individual that you are talking to; like a friend or sibling with kids.
-
April 8, 2021 at 12:28 pm #65991
ritadebur
ParticipantHi- I think it sounds conversational for the most part except towards the end (the last sentence) when it sounded rushed and therefore not conversational anymore.
Congratulations on recording ur demo btw!-
April 8, 2021 at 1:04 pm #65992
Official81
ParticipantTHank you Rita! Yes I did hear that to when I was running out of breath. I forgot to mention that I am also practicing doing short reels in 1 breath. So I did kinda hammer out that last line. Thank you so much for your feedback and your congrats!!! I am so excited!
-
-
-
April 7, 2021 at 10:55 pm #65963
mkell755
ParticipantHi everyone! Here are 2 recordings for any and all feedback. Working on sounding conversational, getting the tone right, pacing, mood, all of it. Let me know what you think. Thank you!!
Mary
Mercury Topaz
It takes more than a single commercial to completely discuss all the advantages of any car. One car recognizes that reality. That car is the Mercury Topaz. Topaz’s approach is quite interesting. It combines front wheel drive, smart traction, and rear suspension. The result is a ride that helps you isolate shock from the driver, while maintaining a superb feel of the road. MERCURY TOPAZ…reaching new heights in automotive technology.Audio Associates
Listen… What do you hear? Nothing. No noise … digital audio purity. The new digital enhanced audio systems from Panasonic will change the way you listen to music. Now listen… What do you hear? Every nuance … crystal clear … like it was meant to sound. So sit down, relax, close your eyes, and get ready for the digital enhanced audio systems from Panasonic. Only at AUDIO ASSOCIATES… there’s no mistaking our sound.Attachments:
You must be logged in to view attached files.-
April 9, 2021 at 2:30 pm #66041
jasjol71
ParticipantAgree with what others have said here, mkell. You have a nice voice to listen to. I thought your second read was better than the Topza commercial. On that one, I personally think you could ramp up the cool/s**y factor and vary your pitch inflection more, as was mentioned above.
-
April 9, 2021 at 10:18 am #66031
Johnwatkis
ParticipantHi Mary,
You have a pleasant tone and your voice is easy to listen to. There were some opportunities to add variety to the pace and pitch in a few sentences that would have changed the feel of both reads. In the Mercury read “One car recognizes that reality.” feels like it should be stated definitively. In Audio Associates, Listen sounds natural the second time you say it, but has no emotion the first time. You’re on the right track!
-
April 8, 2021 at 1:43 pm #66000
Sherry Newell
ParticipantHi Mary!
I thought it was very clear and its obvious that you have been practicing :), good job! I did feel like it was maybe a little obvious that you were reading. Try to imagine speaking to a friend or family member about this new product that you’re excited about and maybe even practice it a few times with a lead in to keep you in the mindset of your normal speech pattern.
-Sherry -
April 8, 2021 at 10:30 am #65976
Official81
ParticipantHello Mary! you sound very clear but I can tell that both scripts are being read. I heard alot of punctuation pauses as well. I am also working on sounding more conversational. So don’t take my word for it. But you sound very nice and clear. I included an attachment of my attempt to sound conversational with your script. Let me know if I sound conversational at all to you.
Attachments:
You must be logged in to view attached files.-
April 14, 2021 at 9:56 pm #66274
mkell755
ParticipantThanks for your feedback Official81! I am definitely working on sounding more conversational without sounding like I’m trying, which is challenging for me. Thanks for including your example, it was nice and flowed well, definitely conversational. Thanks!
Mary
-
April 8, 2021 at 10:31 am #65978
Official81
ParticipantI didn’t complete any edits it is totally raw.
-
April 8, 2021 at 8:24 pm #66023
Lilbelle1487
ParticipantI really like your energy, but it seems rushed and as if you are running out of air. And I got lost a couple times, had to re listen, however your end is really well done.
-
April 14, 2021 at 9:58 pm #66275
mkell755
ParticipantThanks for your feedback Lilbelle! Yes I do sometimes run out of air, which is so weird to me (I work out, I promise!), but in an effort to not make excessive noise I can almost hold me breath when I really need to breathe. Definitely needs practice. Thanks again!
Mary
-
-
-
-
April 7, 2021 at 8:54 pm #65953
juliees206@gmail.com
ParticipantHi, Your feedback for the following is welcomed and appreciated…thx!
.
American Express
Do you know me? Probably not. In my business, recognition is always important, but when I’m buying goods online I prefer a little privacy. With Private Payments from American Express, I get the security of a unique number created for each business transaction I make. Because my private information is my business, and American Express keeps it that way.Purina One Brand 2
Purina One Special Formula For Cats is made with real chicken. Good news for your cat. Great news for your canary. For a complete adult diet for your cat and the real chicken he wants, give him Purina One Special Formula. Your canary will thank you for it. Purina One. Second to none.Attachments:
You must be logged in to view attached files.-
April 9, 2021 at 2:33 pm #66042
jasjol71
ParticipantI had the impression that the echo was affecting my evaluation of the read, which seemed really good otherwise. I liked your energy and how much variation in pitch inflection you demonstrated. On the first recording I would land harder on the word “KEEPS it that way.” I am not a great person to give advice on audio equipment but I am getting good results from a higher-end USB mic. Much better than just using the built-in laptop mic.
-
April 13, 2021 at 9:12 pm #66221
juliees206@gmail.com
ParticipantThank you so much for your feedback and suggestion for the first reading. I will definitely look for a USB mic too!
-
-
April 8, 2021 at 1:36 pm #65999
Sherry Newell
ParticipantHey 🙂
I thought you sounded pretty good overall. I liked the pacing and the smile. On the Purina read, I felt like you lost a little energy just right at the end. Also, maybe it just didn’t come through very clear, but really make sure you pronounce Purina well.
-Sherry-
April 13, 2021 at 9:15 pm #66222
juliees206@gmail.com
ParticipantThank you so much, I’ll be sure to keep the energy up at end/Purina pronunciation. 🙂
-
-
April 7, 2021 at 11:04 pm #65966
mkell755
ParticipantHi Julie, good reads! I’m hearing a little bit of echo in your recordings. I like your energy in both reads – good pacing and emphasis on key words for both. Good smile in your voice for the second script – good job!
Mary
-
April 8, 2021 at 10:03 am #65975
juliees206@gmail.com
ParticipantThanks Mary! I was trying to practice finding/hitting some key words so glad that there was some success! 🙂
I am just recording off of laptop speakers, do you have any suggestions on equipment?
-
April 14, 2021 at 10:10 pm #66279
mkell755
ParticipantHi Julie! Sorry it took me so long to respond back to your question, I hope you see this! I was practicing for about 3 months, recording on a free app on my cell phone before I got my first mic, interface, real headphones and PIB (portable isolation booth). Once I started listening through the headphones / interface I could hear so much more vs. just my desktop speakers, which are ok (small Bose set) but harder to hear over other room noise for me. I took the Home Studio 101 class with Dan a while back and took good notes; he has great suggestions. Then I worked with Sweetwater (they have excellent customer service, and no I do not work there or have any connection with the company). They are super helpful in working with you. I suggest the Home Studio 101 class through Edge as it gives you the basics of what to look for once you get your studio set up. I could go on and on! Will check back later. Thanks!
Mary
-
-
-
-
April 7, 2021 at 5:07 pm #65945
CYeschenko
ParticipantContinued practice! Any comments are appreciated, especially those focused on performance and the style of read- I am much more comfortable with commercial reads and narration, so working on corporate materials is to help broaden the scope of work that I am able to record. Thanks!
Upstart Corporate Conference
Welcome back everyone. In this next segment, we’re going to be looking at the evolution of our selling methodology. Like we said before, UpStart’s target demographic is millennials, and how they want to be sold to is unlike any generation before them.
In fact, many of you may be millennials, or be just like millennials yourselves – and that’s why you’re a good fit for this job. You’re the kind of consumer who is checking online reviews, looking at a company’s Instagram, Facebook and Snapchat, and really buying into a company’s branding and ethos before you’re ‘sold.’
That’s why UpStart preaches a relationship-focused sales strategy. We will equip you with the time, resources and backup to build strong, authentic relationships with potential clients, instead of pushing a product at all costs.
It’s integral that our clients have a real, normal human first interaction with our sales staff, where we simply tell them what we’re offering, and educate them on the state of the startup scene in their market. It’s absolutely vital that you don’t rush the first date at UpStart. Interested clients have seen our Instagram ads, they get it.
We want to make them feel like they’re having a link up with a buddy in a coffee shop.Attachments:
You must be logged in to view attached files.-
April 9, 2021 at 2:35 pm #66043
jasjol71
ParticipantVery nice. I have little to add to the previous comments, which I totally agree with. Great voice/timbre for this genre and appropriate pacing. I think Katelyn already gave tons of good advice.
-
April 8, 2021 at 4:18 pm #66015
mara_sherman
ParticipantYour tone is great, and you speak very clearly. It’s just a little fast. You may want to slow down just a tad.
-
April 7, 2021 at 11:08 pm #65967
mkell755
ParticipantHi Cyeschenko, really well done! You have a great voice for this genre. Very clear, understandable and approachable. The pacing was great too – quick enough to inform without boring the listener. I was really buying into the approach presented. Well done!
Mary
-
April 7, 2021 at 9:50 pm #65956
katelyndawnvo
ParticipantYou have a really nice tone of voice for this and a very marketable voice at that. I think you could warm it up a bit, it sounds more like a documentary piece which is typically read more “matter of factly” without bringing in your personal opinions into it and letting the listener figure out how they feel about what you are presenting on their own. I think you can guide the listener into feeling how you feel about this content. Right now you sound distant from it, like an observer. Can you warm it up, bring a smile to your face and connect more with the copy? I think this will help people to stay engaged in this “eLearning” style script. Right now you sound a little bit bored about what you’re talking about. I’d love to hear this again with this feedback applied, I think you can totally nail it.
-
April 7, 2021 at 5:39 pm #65948
RYoung
ParticipantExcellent delivery on this narration corporate style.
-
-
AuthorReplies
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.