Feedback Forum

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #15468
    David Goldberg
    Edge Studio Staff

    Hi! Upload your recordings, and get feedback from your peers!

Viewing 3,169 reply threads
  • Author
    Replies
  • #65759
    Mdmcghee34
    Participant

    Hello everyone! I am working on narration script homework. Could you provide specific feedback on the script below? Does my read sound conversational, does the script match my voice? how is my diction. Thank you for your time.

    Starlings
    It’s a mesmerizing sight: Thousands of birds move in unison through the evening sky, whirling and swooping as if performing a highly synchronized ballet. When they finally descend to their treetop roost, the beating of their iridescent wings creates such a rush of sound that the noise earned the phenomenon its unusual name: a murmuration of starlings.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
  • #65754
    carynbell
    Participant

    Hey all! So here’s my first student recordings done in my first home studio I got last week. Feedback is appreciated. Thanks!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #65761
      Mdmcghee34
      Participant

      Hello! You have a warm calm voice that I enjoyed. the tone was great for all 3. for the first script, the beginning seemed a little choppy and could come together more; the 2nd and 3rd scripts I would slow down the pace just a little and really embrace the copy. I think everything else sound good.

  • #65748
    Robert Broussard
    Participant

    I ran across this script and thought it may be fun to do.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
  • #65731
    Bil-Bo
    Participant

    Esurance
    If a phone rings at your car insurance company, and no one’s around to hear it… does it make a sound?
    Or… if a tree falls on your car, and no one’s around to answer the call, do YOU make a sound?
    The answer is probably… yes, and, like a howler monkey.
    Unless you’re calling esurance. They have live humans on the line to help you 24/7.
    So you might make different sounds, like happy human sounds.
    Esurance. Insurance for the modern world.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #65781
      Shmuel
      Participant

      Nailed it again, Bil-Bo. You kept it moving, impressive, I would have paused too much, me thinks. I’m wondering why you add the music and sound affects here in this forum. It makes it a full professional piece, but is that what we are doing here? I’m not sure.

    • #65741
      Erik B
      Participant

      Hi Bil-Bo, this read is excellent and sounds professional. The tone, tempo, and recording quality are all top notch. Great job.

  • #65726

    I’ve included 2 scripts for practice and feedback, any feedback is appreciated! 🙂

    Sandals-In The Mood
    What’s your mood?…13 Luxury Included resorts…4 Exotic Islands…ONE unforgettable experience…Sandals—The Luxury Included vacation…Call 1-800-Sandals or visit Sandals.com

    Ziploc
    Only Ziploc brand bags have a unique interlocking zipper to lock in freshness in a way no other bag can. When it comes out this fresh, you know it went in a Ziploc bag. Ziploc. We’ve got a lock on freshness.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #65782
      Shmuel
      Participant

      Agree with Robert, No.2 is way better than No.1, which sounds sultry, to be honest. With No.2 keep it moving a bit more. It’s got some good pop and upbeat feel.

      • #65950

        Thank you so much for your feedback, was trying to have fun with sounding sultry for No. 1 and appreciate your suggestions for No. 2 in which I’ll practice 🙂

    • #65750
      Robert Broussard
      Participant

      Julie, I liked #2 better it had more engery. #1 could be more upbeat. Hope this helps.

      • #65951

        Thanks Robert, really appreciate your comment on #2 and will work on the energy for #1 too!

  • #65724
    artyom123
    Participant

    Looking for feedback on this script, it may sound because the read called for a 30 sec slot. looking for emotional connection, story telling.. what I can improve. I made 3 takes, Thank you all..

    I heard the call
    And I moved with a purpose.
    When the objective is in front of me, my path is clear.
    And out here, it’s no different. My mission has changed, but my purpose remains.
    American Military University was founded by a veteran.
    The faculty knows where I’m coming from, and where I want to go.
    They made the mission and they’ve got my 6—
    From enrollment to beyond graduation.
    The classes and degrees are built around outcomes—giving graduates career relevant knowledge and skills.
    After service, we start a new mission. With AMU, that mission is clear.
    It’s time to start your next mission.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #65952

      I really like the warmth in your voice! For the story telling, perhaps you could try adding more emphasis by hitting different words to capture more of the listener’s attention~

  • #65712
    SuperLuke
    Participant

    My demo is coming up soon in April and I wanted to rehearse my characters to see if they are in good shape. Please feel free to leave feedback about my performance, the characters, and so on.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #65718
      artyom123
      Participant

      nice demo and good character selection and leaning into the character. my only advice is that I couldn’t make out some of what the characters were saying. it seems like they are either screaming, or ultra calm. I would take those same characters and see what they sound like in a conversational tone. good luck !

      • #65822
        SuperLuke
        Participant

        Thank you for the comment and wishing me luck, I’m excited and nervous at the same time. Yeah, some of my characters are loud, calm, maybe yelling. I probably should have slowed down my characters so they were audible too. Also, my microphone was tilted the wrong way and it made my voice not go through properly. I’ll try again, with the adjustment made.
        Thanks again

  • #65695
    Andrea
    Participant

    Hi everyone,

    Here’s another homework practice script. I’m on a narration track and would appreciate any feedback on performance (I don’t have all my studio stuff yet).

    Thanks for your help!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #65703
      SuperLuke
      Participant

      Good narration voice for a History channel, or Discovery channel documentary. If that’s what you were going for, great job. I would encourage you to provide a script of what you are narrating, in case your coach or peers want to follow along.
      Keep up the good work

      • #65722
        Andrea
        Participant

        Thanks for the feedback! I’ll remember to provide the script next time.

  • #65686
    mkell755
    Participant

    Hi everyone! Here is the same recording, with 2 background audio files for any and all feedback. Working on making it sound warm, inviting and conversational. Let me know what you think about the tone, pace, performance, all of it. Thank you!

    Mary

    Grey Goose V***a
    This is where musicians go to hear each other play. The room is alive. The crowd is full of familiar, knowing faces whose expressions are as much a part of the performance as the music itself. From this room, you’re transported to places all over the world and feelings from all over your life. That’s why you come here, to be taken there. Grey Goose. World’s Best Tasting V***a.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #65747
      Robert Broussard
      Participant

      Mary, I think the first recording was better. The background music suited the dialog and tone of your voice much better than the 2nd recording. The 1st was very appealing to listening to compared to the 2nd. Good job.

      • #65962
        mkell755
        Participant

        Thanks for the feedback Robert! Agree that the first one sounded more relaxed and suited for the commercial’s vibe. Thanks again!!

        Mary

    • #65729

      Hi Mary, I liked both of your recordings, thought the first recording was more conversational and inviting. I liked the second recording too but was listening more to the music than your words.

      • #65961
        mkell755
        Participant

        Thanks for the feedback Julie! Yes, now that I’m hearing this again, the music int he second one was a bit distracting, I too was focused in on it more so that listening to what was being said. Thank you!

        Mary

    • #65719
      artyom123
      Participant

      great emotional connection and tone. you have a nice passionate voice and what you could do to improve the read is to be a bit more conversational.

      • #65960
        mkell755
        Participant

        Thanks for the feedback Artyom! I will work on the conversational part of it, that piece has been a bit of a challenge for me. Thanks again!

        Mary

    • #65704
      Erik B
      Participant

      Hi Mary, I like both performances. Your tone, tempo, and pacing are very good. Also the recording quality sounds good. The only critique I have, is I hear pauses in two places, that perhaps shouldn’t be there, betweeen room and is and also between faces and whose. But overall good job.

      • #65959
        mkell755
        Participant

        Thanks for the feedback Erik! I think I edited out breaths in those places that you mentioned; they sounded too breathy to me when listening to them closely. I will work on that. Thank you!

        Mary

    • #65697
      Andrea
      Participant

      Hi Mary,

      I like your warm voice. I think the first recording sounds more inviting than the second one, probably because of the background audio. If you go with the second background audio, I think there should be a bit more energy in the delivery. But I’m new to this, so I might be wrong 🙂
      In both recordings, I would contrast “here” and “there” more.

      • #65958
        mkell755
        Participant

        Thanks for the feedback Andrea! Good points. I was going for a relaxed vibe, so I agree that the first one’s music fit the intended mood better. I’ll also work on emphasizing the contrasted words – thanks!

        Mary

      • #65705
        SuperLuke
        Participant

        Hi Mary,
        Both recordings were good, having music, your warm voice, and well-paced performance. The first recording sounds more inviting, well-paced, tone, conveying the right emotion(s). The second recording was good too. But the music was taking away from your audio performance.

        • #65957
          mkell755
          Participant

          Thanks for the feedback SuperLuke! Now that I am listening to it again, I agree – the second one gets overshadowed by the music. Thanks!

          Mary

  • #65679
    artyom123
    Participant

    Hello, Would love to head if I emotionally connected to the script to deliver it’s message, and what I could do to further deepen my emotional connection to the read and bering it more to life. Thanks!

    Script 1:
    With people gravitating to the newest craft bourbons, Marker’s Mark needed to connect to new audiences beyond conventional whiskey drinkers. Maker’s Mark needed to rethink authenticity to include other people’s origin stories, not just its own.

    Script 2:
    If you’re managing contractors to service, support, repair, upgrade, and maintain the equipment, vehicles and other assets you have, you’re used to complexity.
    On any given day, any given piece of work requires different people, skills, and hours – and it’s all changing all the time.

    SAP Fieldglass Assignment Management provides an elegant solution to a complex problem. Learn more about it on Fieldglass.com.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #65717
      artyom123
      Participant

      thank you so much for the feedback, really taking it to heart!

    • #65698
      Andrea
      Participant

      Hi Artyom,
      Nice work! I agree with Mary. The second version of Script 2 is much better than the first one. Finding the list items at different pitches makes a huge difference. I wouldn’t pause after SAP.
      For Script 1, maybe try to make it sound more inspirational? Think of who you are in the story and who you’re talking to.

    • #65692
      mkell755
      Participant

      Hi Artyom, good job on these! You have a nice warm and friendly voice and both of these genres are good for your voice.
      Script 1: I heard “to a new audience” instead of “to new audiences” as it is written. Otherwise, very good pacing and good choice of emphasized words.
      Script 2: I liked the second version better than the first – good pacing and variation throughout. Keep it up!

      Mary

Viewing 3,169 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.