Feedback Forum

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #15468
    David Goldberg
    Edge Studio Staff

    Hi! Upload your recordings, and get feedback from your peers!

Viewing 3,169 reply threads
  • Author
    Replies
  • #95784
    Terra Ashe
    Participant

    Hi! I’m working on scripts to add a PSA spot to my demo. I will only end up choosing one, and all are just drafts below, so plenty of room to change things. Would love any feedback. Thanks!

    *sounds of searching through room and angry sounds”Where is it?”* Can’t find your vape? Now you’re irritable, restless, and running late…again Don’t let vaping control you.
    #PowerOverVape
    Visit PowerOverVape.com to learn more.

    It didn’t matter what I was doing. Taking a test, at soccer practice, babysitting…all I wanted to do was hit my vape. It as all I could think about. I couldn’t concentrate, I was snapping at my friends and family. My vape was controlling my life. That is until I learned about #PowerOverVape. And I took that control back. Visit PowerOverVape.com to learn more.

    Can’t stop scrolling? I get it, social media is designed to keep us locked in. But while we keep scrolling inside, the world keeps moving outside. Let’s turn that scrolling into stroll #StrollOverScroll. To learn more visit StrollOverScroll.com

    Phone Ding ding ding, text clicking, car crash, siren
    Texting while driving has dangerous consequences. Make sure you’re alive to respond back Visit TextLatertoSaveHer.com to learn more.

  • #95771
    JamesB
    Participant

    Hi everyone. Doing the demo practices and coaching sessions. Please give a listen and some constructive feedback if you have the time. I look forward to the feedback. Also, the audio seems much more quiet in MP3 format than the initial recording. If you find the recording to be too quiet too, let me know and if you have any useful tips I’m all ears. Using audacity with a Scarlett Solo 4-gen and a Rode NT-1 mic. Thank you all for your time.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #95973
      Artist7
      Participant

      Hi, JamesB! Your voice is nice and works well for both scripts. However, it does sound as if you’re reading the scripts in some places-particularly in the first half of the Principal script and in the Quicken one, too. I agree with Terra Ashe that more energy in your tone/delivery would probably help. Keep up the good work!

    • #95948
      Terra Ashe
      Participant

      Principal- You have a lovely voice! I think this script needs a more excited tone in the beginning. Your tone now tells me this Ron is sad and we are doing him a favor. but the words tell a different story, “Ron has been looking forward to March since last march” and now its March so it’s time for him to solve your problem!

      Quiken- Loved your “How easy is that” button!, Small thing but I’d try recording a take without the pause between some people-Like. Also your energy is pretty similar through the entire thing, try having a bigger tonal/energy shift from “some people are crazy and do it themselves” to the “but you aren’t that person you want an easy to use solution like quicken”

  • #95741
    Artist7
    Participant

    Hi, everyone! I’d really love some feedback on whether these two reads sound conversational. Thanks so much!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #95775
      JamesB
      Participant

      Hello Artist7! Of the two, I think Discover Publishers was perfect. It had the right mix of conversational sound and high energy to catch my attention for such a short spot.

      The Handcrafted Coffee sounded like a smooth read, the right sound that would catch my ear for coffee. To me, the lack of pauses keeps it from being conversational. I think it’s a 30-second spot and you managed it in 22 seconds, which is impressive. I think you could afford to add a few pauses and stretch it out to 30-seconds and that would make this one sound conversational.

      • #95975
        Artist7
        Participant

        Thanks for the feedback-I really appreciate it!

  • #95715
    Earthbul
    Participant

    Any feedback would be appreciated. Especially on sound quality. Thanks

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #95776
      JamesB
      Participant

      I agree with Artist7. Your voice sounds perfect for this commercial. It is just a little “flat” of delivery to me, and that is keeping it from being conversational to my ear.

    • #95744
      Artist7
      Participant

      Overall read is good including sound quality. Would try to make it sound just a bit more conversational.

  • #95642
    AllAirlinesOffice
    Participant

    Southwest Airlines Jamaica Office

  • #95626

    Hi everyone…just practicing!

    Creative feedback only please! No technical feedback please!

    How is my diction? How is my pace? Do my reads sound conversational?

    Please let me know…thank you!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #95777
      JamesB
      Participant

      The Apple commercial sounds conversational to me. The diction is very good aside from a missed the splosive “p” on “specifically” but that is the only minor diction thing that caught my ear. Good job.

      The Bed Bath and Beyond commercial sounds conversational except the pacing is a little fast. Diction sounded good to me. Again, good job.

  • #95625
    Brian Lakes
    Participant

    Hello everyone!! I am looking for an accountability group. Are any of you in one? Is it beneficial? I live in Colorado and would love to be part of one or start one with someone. I look forward to hearing from you all! You can email me at Brian@brianlakes.com if interested.

  • #95581
    Honeyvoice
    Participant

    This is my Homework for vo narration coaching.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #95778
      JamesB
      Participant

      I didn’t see a response on here, and due to the date this is probably a little late but here it is anyways. I think you nailed it. That sounded perfect for a Corporate Training Video. I liked the pacing and your delivery was clear. Good Job.

  • #95329
    DillonP
    Participant

    It has been quite sometime I had done anything with the feedback form. So I just did two commercial recordings and hope for some feedback. I need to get more focus on my goals more often and get out there more. I would really appreciate the feedback, it will be very helpful to me in the future and will make more of an effort to do so more often.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #95518
      Terra Ashe
      Participant

      Pizza Hut: I would combine the energy of the first take with the pace of the second take.

      4kidsTV: Slow down on the first couple words I had a hard time catching what was said, you could also give some more emphasis to the adjective “more”
      Maybe give yourself a lead in to this, remember you are talking to kids so really bring it to life, you are still giving info so it doesn’t need to be crazy but you can bring some more energy to it.
      Nice read though, I definitely think you have a good voice for stuff marketed to kids!

  • #95316
    Tom_S
    Participant

    The first few times I recorded this, I went way too fast. This seems to be a tendency. I would appreciate any feedback on pacing, tone, or anything else. Thank you!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #95516
      Terra Ashe
      Participant

      Your tone and pace is lovely I think you can have some more variation from the first half problem being stated part to the second half of we have a solution. A lot of mouth noise and I would give yourself a lead in to help get into it. But nice read!

      • #95520
        Tom_S
        Participant

        Thank you for the feedback. This is helpful!

Viewing 3,169 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.