Feedback Forum

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #15468
    David Goldberg
    Edge Studio Staff

    Hi! Upload your recordings, and get feedback from your peers!

Viewing 3,056 reply threads
  • Author
    Replies
  • #79142
    nicolance
    Participant

    Hi again – this was for 10 second digital ad audition – “looking for cool voice with swagger”. Did you feel the swagger? Thanks, Lance

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #79153
      Jaljr
      Participant

      Yeah…I liked the second read as well. It had an extra measure of swagger that the first read lacked. Tough to get capture “too cool for school” in 10 secs, but I think you got it. Great read!!

    • #79146
      samsheeks
      Participant

      Loved the second read! I would even take it a bit further to really grab the attention in those 10 short seconds. Great work!

  • #79140
    nicolance
    Participant

    Audition sample sent for male VO for safety video: “read needs to sound experienced but friendly” Your feedback please? – Thanks, Lance

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #79154
      Jaljr
      Participant

      Hey, Lance – great read. That feels like a tough script to get the message across while still sounding “friendly and experienced.” You got them both though. I agree that the tempo felt slow. But you gotta hit the points in the script and make them all sound important

    • #79145
      samsheeks
      Participant

      Great job on sounding experienced and friendly! I would just speed it up a tad. A little more urgency to keep the listener interested.

  • #79136
    Joe Slade
    Participant

    Hello Feedback Forum,

    I’m currently working on my narration demo and would love some feedback on these two sample script reads.
    Does my read sound conversational?🤔 ( I’m not working from a professional home studio yet, so I’m not quite ready for any technical feedback )

    Thanks so much for taking the time to listen and share your thoughts.

    • #79155
      Jaljr
      Participant

      Great reads, Joe!! Definitely conversational.
      Both should have a wide eyed feel (for different reasons lol). I liked the earth origin read better.

      • #79220
        Joe Slade
        Participant

        Hey Jaljr! Thanks so much for the great feedback here. I liked your mention of a “wide-eyed feel” for both reads. 🙂

    • #79137
      Joe Slade
      Participant

      Reformatted audio files attached 🙂

      Attachments:
      You must be logged in to view attached files.
      • #79144
        samsheeks
        Participant

        Great reads! Definitely sounds conversational, I was just missing a bit of excitement/wonder. And be careful of dropping your tone at the ends of words, a few words were lost because of this.

        • #79221
          Joe Slade
          Participant

          Hey Samsheeks!
          Thanks so much for sharing your thoughts on these reads here. I really appreciate your notes on dropping tone and adding a bit of wonder/excitement in reads where that extra energy is such a good fit. Great feedback all around!

  • #79119
    samsheeks
    Participant

    I did two different takes of this fun infomercial!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #79156
      Jaljr
      Participant

      These were really good. Created urgency in the ad without raising your voice while still getting the message out. I liked both.

  • #79116
    samsheeks
    Participant

    A couple more!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #79157
      Jaljr
      Participant

      The Allstate read had the feeling of you putting an arm around the listener and showing them how to achieve their life goals. Good, intimate read. Drew the listener in…

      Advil was good as well. Clearly explaining the product and its benefits in an authoritative tone in what felt like a tough script to read.

      Thanks for these

  • #79112
    samsheeks
    Participant

    Hi all! Working on my second round of assignments. Would love some feedback, as always!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #79314
      Silver Wit
      Participant

      I liked your waterpik read, though I feel like you could up the tempo in the beginning and the end of the commercial. The tempo in the middle sounded perfect to me.

    • #79132
      IlikeGlen
      Participant

      Hi Samsheeks
      Tone sounds good I would try to read straight through without the pauses

  • #79104
    gigihernandezdoesit
    Participant

    ATTN SPANISH SPEAKERS// folks working in the Spanish/Spanglish commercial genre! Will you take a listen?
    I’m a commercial genre kindergartner and basically an infant when it comes to doing any VO in Spanish, so any and all performance/technique notes are appreciated! Strongly considering adding some bilingual fun to my first demo.
    Not looking for technical or sound quality notes today, just ~general~. always aiming at natural, conversational, and understandable.

    I also ran the Ziploc piece a couple times for fun. Still trying to pin down what my signature voice is so, gonna keep trying a few different styles in the forum.

    • This reply was modified 3 years, 1 month ago by gigihernandezdoesit. Reason: forgot to upload!
    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #79127
      SuperLuke
      Participant

      Hello Feedback Forum,
      I am working on my Audiobook Demo and wanted to share some of my practice recordings before a session next week. All input is appreciated!
      Thanks,
      -SuperLuke

      Attachments:
      You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #79122
      samsheeks
      Participant

      Ziploc: Great understanding of the script and your voice is perfect for this spot. It got a bit staccato towards the end where the thought could be smoothed out. I did hear some sounds that sounded like bumping the mic… not sure what they’re from but they were distracting.

  • #79084
    IlikeGlen
    Participant

    Hello Fellow Voice Actors, I would love to hear what you all think of my practice recordings thanks for taking the time to listen in advance.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #79123
      samsheeks
      Participant

      Lovely voice to listen to! I would like to hear more variety between your spots and within each spot. More connection to the script, perhaps? You have a very distinct “performing” voice that could sound more natural.

      • #79159
        IlikeGlen
        Participant

        Thanks samsheeks superluke
        Gigihernande?thanks for the great feedback your constructive thoughts are fantastic thank you

    • #79108
      SuperLuke
      Participant

      I like how you slated your name and then performed the copy. Maybe add some deeper tone, similar to the “Allstate” guy on TV. Anyway, it was a nice recording to listen to. Keep up the practice!

    • #79101
      gigihernandezdoesit
      Participant

      Hi Glen! I really liked your instinct to get soft and intimate in the potennix spot, but I think you have a distinct rhythm that you hit almost like a metronome, that makes it a lil monotonous. Definitely feel free to play around with your tempo more. I felt similarly about the mortgage holder piece. Jumping in on a phrase like “the cinema has no boundary,” is so epic ! maybe try to lead in slowly and then warm up as you get to recommendation part of the spot, just for some more dynamism. <3 good luck!

  • #79051
    IlikeGlen
    Participant

    Hi Fellow Voice Actor’s must speak it into existence here I two recordings I did from the practice manual I would greatly appreciate your feedback hanks in advance

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #79077
      Mike T
      Participant

      I like the variety between the two spots! The delivery for both spots felt fast. I think if you can slow the pacing down a bit it will help take these to the next level.

  • #79037
    Audrea23
    Participant

    Hello everyone –
    First time posting to the forum and looking for some feedback on my pacing as well as my tone. I’m definitely more comfortable with the eLearning and IVR, I also wanted to try my hand at something different from my preferred genre (Words Can Do Anything mp3) and would love to hear feedback on ways I can improve.
    Note: I do not have my home studio fully set up yet, but if you have technical and/or creative input I’d appreciate it!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #79158
      Jaljr
      Participant

      Hey Audrea
      Great reads
      Pitch to close had the right tone and tempo for my ear and was engaging to keep the listener moving
      The spa telephony sounded just right
      Words needs some more variety in tone and pitch. I wasn’t sure of the mood you were trying to set.

    • #79110
      SuperLuke
      Participant

      Hi Audrea.
      I liked the copy of the eLearning. You have a nice voice. Maybe work on breath support so that you can perform the copy without unnecessary pauses in between the sentences. I could hear some breathiness and pauses between words at times. I think that can easily be fixed by trying the copy a couple of different ways, like having more emphasis on keywords that the listener of the ad needs to hear. Maybe sound more dynamic, adding some more energy to the copy that can be informative, interesting, and hold the listener’s attention. I’m sure you can find the right pace that works for you.

    • #79046
      ikrani
      Participant

      On your “Words Can Do Anything” read, I think your pitch was a little too narrow for the first 18 seconds. Once you got to “Like the human rights activist-“, your pitch range seemed to widen slightly, and it makes you sound more invested in what you’re saying, more authoritative. You sounded like you wanted us to take this stuff seriously, lest we find ourselves in a similar situation. The emphases on “human”, “journalist”, and “thousands” saw a gradual rise in your peak pitch for each one, like talking about these injustices was subtly getting to you.

      Prior to that, I was having trouble getting a fix on what mood you were trying to set. You were talking about positive stuff like birthdays and friends with a lack of investment, like someone reading a grocery list aloud. What you might consider is, if not widening the pitch range in the first part, perhaps moving the highs and lows a little higher, so there’s a slightly more noticeable rug-pull as you down-shift along the route of, “Friends, birthdays, human rights violations.”

      • #79055
        Audrea23
        Participant

        Thank you so much! Words Can Do Anything was challenging for me – I wasn’t sure what the mood “should” be and the “happy” things, in the beginning, were very confusing with the more somber things detailed at the end. I’m going to take your feedback to my Coach so I can work on the areas you pointed out. I definitely prefer eLearning and telephony but I want to improve in other areas and your comments were VERY helpful!

Viewing 3,056 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.