Feedback Forum

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #15468
    David Goldberg
    Edge Studio Staff

    Hi! Upload your recordings, and get feedback from your peers!

Viewing 3,056 reply threads
  • Author
    Replies
  • #81401
    Declan Waters
    Participant

    Good Evening All,

    A couple practice scripts. Would appreciate any feedback!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #81409
      jadethevo
      Participant

      Loved Six Flags! You did a great job acting, and making distinctions between the different “no”s. I think for Ancient Mysteries, you needed just a little bit more of a deeper inhale before you started, it sounded like you were losing your breath a bit with each word. Still pretty good, though.

      • #81435
        Declan Waters
        Participant

        Tremendously valuable, thanks so much!

  • #81394
    billmull
    Participant

    Hello,

    I would appreciate any feedback as to how conversational I sound. I am not looking for feedback regarding recording quality.

    The script is from Edge Studio’s script library.

    Thanks,

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #81440
      Grace17
      Participant

      Your voice sounds really clear with great enunciation. I think you’re getting there with the conversational aspect. I don’t quite feel as an audience member that you’re talking to me. It still has a manufactured sort of robotic tone to it. I advice choosing someone you have a relationship with in real life and REALLY talking to them while still enunciating words well like you do. Practice makes it easier. Forget that you’re recording or putting on a performance and focus on your intent in speaking to your imagined person.

  • #81377
    Hazaro
    Participant

    More practice in varying commercial reads. Any feedback welcome.

    • This reply was modified 2 years, 11 months ago by Hazaro.
    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #81441
      Grace17
      Participant

      You have a very nice clear voice, with great enunciation. However, the tones used for these two reads don’t match or make sense with the message so the attitude you gave seemed disconnected from the message to me. So I would say try to integrate the attitude with the words or message, so it’s believable that these are your words.

  • #81369
    Jefftuttle
    Participant

    Hi, Everyone! I’m submitting a couple of practice reads for a homework assignment I’m working on. I’d definitely appreciate feedback. Thanks

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #81400
      becksflatt
      Participant

      nice! both of these really show off your warm inviting tone

    • #81399
      billmull
      Participant

      I like the ACS read very much. The only thing that struck me was the way you read the first sentence, i.e. “It’s tough to quit smoking.” You read it in a kind of matter of fact way, almost too matter of fact. I suspect that someone who has struggled with quitting smoking would say this with more conviction. Otherwise, awesome read!

      As far as “Jazz-Radio” goes, it’s been a while since I’ve listened to commercial radio, but the beginning of this sounded much too slow and low key. I think more excitement would work better especially towards the beginning. But your deep voice certainly sounds like it has excellent potential for radio imaging.

    • #81397
      Pamela B
      Participant

      Really liked the jazz radio read, sounded like you were having fun with it.

  • #81367
    SamWaxmanVoice
    Participant

    Hi all. Attaching some narration homework below, and would love anyone’s thoughts. Appreciate it!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #81393
      Hazaro
      Participant

      Great pacing, tone, and clarity! I love the expression you bring to this. With your voice having such a natural gravitas quality, feel like you could do even less and the intonations would still be there. You got more lighthearted as it went through which was fun.

  • #81361
    jadethevo
    Participant

    (Trying this again, my files didn’t upload properly and I can’t edit my post)

    Hello, fellow VO folks!

    I’m looking for feedback on these reads, nothing technical though.

    Take 1 & 2 I tried to vary the intonation and pacing, Take 3 was an attempt to sound more conversational. Take 4 was me winging it, and trying to match my voice to what I imagined the visuals might convey.

    Thanks in advance for the constructive feedback!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #81389
      Lyle Blaker
      Participant

      Great work. I really like take 1. Your personality came out nicely and has energy but not pushed. For my money, I’d love to hear the energy of the first line a little more throughout the rest of the commercial, that makes sense. Well done!

    • #81375
      Hazaro
      Participant

      Thought you did a great job with these! Heard the difference with each and they all sounded organic.

  • #81360
    jadethevo
    Participant

    Hello, fellow VO folks!

    I’m looking for feedback on these reads, nothing technical though.

    Take 1 & 2 I tried to vary the intonation and pacing, Take 3 was an attempt to sound more conversational. Take 4 was me winging it, and trying to match my voice to what I imagined the visuals might convey.

    Thanks in advance for the constructive feedback!

  • #81356
    Grace17
    Participant

    Hi everyone,
    I’m practicing presenting different attitudes. I’ll appreciate feedback on the believability and any other technique tips. I was going for motivated without too much excitement in the last audio but it doesn’t seem to me like it came off as very motivated. What do you think? Thanks in advance!

    note: In this script, there are actions that are meant to be taken in between the phrases so that’s why it probably sounds a bit disjointed. Like I’m supposed to interact with a cashier using my coins checkout app, then leave the coffee with the good news.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #81396
      billmull
      Participant

      Hi,

      Nice job!

      You sound believably excited across all three reads, but I’m not sure I was picking up so much on differences in attitude. The excitement in the “awkward” version may have been slightly muted but still excited.

      The excitement in your voice comes across as motivated across all three reads not only the “motivated” version.

      Just my thoughts.

      • #81426
        Grace17
        Participant

        Thank you, I appreciate your insight:)

  • #81349
    JeffBukowski
    Participant

    So, I was letting myself get caught in obsessiveness about getting these perfect before I posted them, until I managed to remind myself that’s…kind of the point, isn’t it?

    Fumbling at commercial and narration/ e-learning. It might be obvious I have more of a head for the E-learning angle at the moment.

    Of note, I’m aware of the mouth clicks, and how that would need to be fixed. That said, any advice on that besides ‘adjust foods’ is welcome: microphone distance, messing with the gain, etc. alongside any other feedback. Of all of these I’m happiest thus far with the second E-learning take and the Social Security take, but! Never done any of these genres before, so I’m a bit adrift!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #81354
      becksflatt
      Participant

      Really nice reads on all of these! They all seem to be at a good volume but Social Security was a little bit quiet. If the gain was the same for all 4 takes you may have been a little far from the mic? I know I sometimes back away from the mic when I’m concerned about mouth sounds so I don’t know if maybe that was a factor here. Even still, not so quiet that it couldn’t do with a little boost in whatever software you’re recording with.

  • #81344
    RCori
    Participant

    Hi All! After a few years I’m finally getting back into the VO game/training so I’m a little rusty. I’m working on sounding less performance and more conversational on my commercial reads, also let me know what you think about the pace (Creative feedback only, not working from a professional home studio yet, NO technical feedback, please!).

    Side note – any tips on raining in the extra saliva while recording is greatly appreciated (I’ve tried lots of water although I’m sure I could always drink more, as well as mouthwash before recording). Thank you!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #81391
      Lyle Blaker
      Participant

      You have a great sound. HookOnPh. read is really nice. I think, based on my own coaching, if you take out some of the glottal stops and smooth out the read just a smidge more, it would be *chef’s kiss* and would likely be the conversational sound you are looking for. The last two sentences were great and a reference for what I mean in smoothing it out. And the Aruba take is also very nice. The natural smile in your tone will get you a lot of work. Spit balling here: I wonder what would happen to your energy level if you did the script in 15 seconds and also got rid of the micro pauses within sentences.

      Mouth noises are such a pain in the b***y. Green apples help (something about the acidity) and honestly, de-mouth click software is a LIFESAVER. I use RX9 software.

      Great work!

    • #81355
      becksflatt
      Participant

      These are really engaging! Hooked on Phonics has such a great inviting feel to it. When listening to Aruba, your voice sounds great but I think I wanted to see the picturesque views in the read. Like listening to a friend who just got back from the best trip of their life.

      I also struggle with extra saliva and am still exploring options for that. Lately, I’ve been popping in a honey throat lozenge before recording and it seems to thicken the saliva so it isn’t so noisy.

Viewing 3,056 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.