Feedback Forum

  • This topic has 10,049 replies, 725 voices, and was last updated 3 weeks ago by G Cobb.
  • Creator
    Topic
  • #15468
    David Goldberg
    Edge Studio Staff

    Hi! Upload your recordings, and get feedback from your peers!

Viewing 3,184 reply threads
  • Author
    Replies
  • #83810
    Nikka Kowidge
    Participant

    Hey Friends! Here’a a quick commercial read about Crayola markers. I’m looking for feedback on how conversational it sounds…
    I don’t need feedback on the tech bc my studio is not set up yet.
    Thank you!!!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #84013
      RCampos
      Participant

      Hi Nikka,
      Your voice sounds great here. A few minor notes:
      I would like to hear a little some variation in the first few words: Crayola Color Wonder Markers.
      Also – you have a pause after this phrase which might be a touch too long. To me it sounds to me like you’re starting a new sentence rather than continuing the first one.
      I agree with punching ONLY more.
      Great job. I just posted a VO called AIG (version 2). Would love your feedback.
      Thanks,
      Robert

    • #84005
      M
      Participant

      lovely voice! My suggestions: color “ONLY” on special paper (not on table, walls etc…)

  • #83777
    Leann
    Participant

    Hey there,
    I have been on hiatus for a while due to… life.
    So anyway, these are for my upcoming session.
    If you have time, take a listen. I still have a lot of work to do within Audacity.
    I appreciate any suggestions and comments! – I edited my post and now have doubled my attached files. There should only be three! whoops 😀
    Thanks lots! 🙂 Leann

    • This reply was modified 2 years, 3 months ago by Leann.
    • This reply was modified 2 years, 3 months ago by Leann.
    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #84065
      RCampos
      Participant

      Hi Leann,
      Nice voice! I think you could relax a bit more here and give this a more human touch. Also, check your diction on the word, “add.” I think you move to the next word too quickly and the “d” in add is a little lost.

      Sunlife2 is better! I think I would be great to warm this up even more. You might try slowing down and think about the person you’re speaking too. Hope that helps. And if you have a moment, I would welcome your feedback on 2 VO’s I just posted today: Congaree and American Gothic. Thank you!

    • #83788
      Shawn
      Participant

      I listened to the Amex and SunLife. Thought they were both warm and friendly. Subtle intonation kept me listening.

  • #83760
    Artist7
    Participant

    Hello! Looking for feedback on these two practice reads. Thanks so much!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #83819
      M
      Participant

      Great job.
      RB thoughts: the connection gets lost by “omega 3”and the song-song of “flax seeds” – I was expecting a list after “seeds”. Loved the emphasis on “plump” and “juicy” – two great words to “taste” when you say them.
      CJ thoughts: great choices on pace and tone! Wonderful delivery suited for your soothing, yet playful, voice. Really nice work!

    • #83789
      Shawn
      Participant

      I thought the cool-jazz reading was great. Seductive voice and enticing read. Very jazzy.

    • #83769
      Earthbul
      Participant

      I enjoyed both reads. I felt biggest and news should’ve flowed a little better. Plus a slight pause between flaxseed & plump juicy raisins. With a slight emphasis on the latter would really bump it up. Heck, now you have wanting to take a shot it lol
      Great job on both. I look forward to hearing your next one.

  • #83698
    Earthbul
    Participant

    American Tire Supply practice read
    Put a little more pep in my step.
    I was in a b****r of a Monday mood but I had fun with recording and editing this one.
    Any thoughts on how to improve upon it are welcomed.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #84006
      RCampos
      Participant

      Lots to compliment here: the burst of “free” at the top, the chuckle, and the “hey” – all nice touches that make this very effective. I would suggest a couple of minor tweaks:
      An ever so slight pause after: a while right? At the moment, the “well” feels like it comes too soon. You’ve got listener hooked and a little pause can build suspense.
      And – “one all weather radial” runs together for me. Just a little differentiation here would help clarify the details of the deal. By the by, I listened to your comments on my AIG VO and made changes – just reloaded today. Would appreciate your take on it. Thanks!

  • #83685
    Debbie
    Participant

    Hello everyone!
    I’m working on being conversational and my glottal stops, so wanted to practice on copy that has key words starting with vowels.
    I’m a little congested so you may be able to hear it. No tech notes please, all other feedback welcome!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #84007
      RCampos
      Participant

      Hi Debbie, very nice job on this VO. I just have a few suggestions:
      It feels like you tightened your throat on the word “scenes.”
      You could enunciate “definitely” more – sounds like you gobble up a syllable in the middle.
      Other than that, I think a little slower would be better, and a touch more of the resonance in your voice. It sounds like most of this is in your “head” voice, rather than from the diaphragm.
      Finally, if you have a moment, I’d appreciate your comments on a VO I just loaded today: AIG. Thanks! Robert

    • #83826
      M
      Participant

      very nice. Keep it going/connected with “this is definitely the place for cross country…etc…”
      maybe mark breaths on the script so you don’t get bogged down with an unnatural inhale.

    • #83754
      Earthbul
      Participant

      I liked your read very much. I felt it was very conversational, laid back and I could hear the smile in your voice. Great enunciation as well. Lovely voice. I’d love to hear you even more relaxed in the read if that makes sense. I feel it would be even better than it is now.

  • #83630
    Jaljr
    Participant

    Hey, folks –
    A couple of lightly edited commercial reads. I value your comments.
    Be well…
    JALKR

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #83820
      M
      Participant

      Deluth: great match for your voice: deep, hint of south, confident, outdoorsy with a hint of a “commanding general” to it. Bravo.
      Acura: seemed less of a fit but perhaps taking out some of the accent, deepening the tone and slowing down could elevate to a more luxurious level.

    • #83696
      VOgalUS
      Participant

      I could hear ‘money’ in your voice for Acura. Your voice would do good for an even more expensive car. The copy for Duluth distracted me from ‘hearing’ you. Buck n***d for a trading company. Clever.

    • #83654
      Earthbul
      Participant

      I enjoyed listeng to your delivery on the Deluth read. Perfect fit. Didn’t feel the same about Acura. You didn’t sound comfortable and it didn’t flow. Also a bit of mouth noise in that one as well. That being said I’d love to hear you do a food or travel piece. You have an awesome folksy delivery. Great work.

  • #83612
    Earthbul
    Participant

    Just experimenting with mixing at the moment.
    Not sure if the music is overpowering or under.
    Thoughts ?

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #84009
      RCampos
      Participant

      Enjoy listening to your reads!
      Just a few notes:
      The “t” in retirement is a bit lost.
      And – almost sounds like a double “d” on He’d – or is there extraneous click there?
      As for the music mix, it’s low enough as to be too distant from the VO. I think if you’re going to use music, it should be more integrated. I would raise the level. All best,
      Robert

    • #83634
      Jaljr
      Participant

      That was a good read. I had to turn it up to get the music in my ears. Certainly not overpowering. Nice job.

  • #83588
    Earthbul
    Participant

    Practice read.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #83812
      Artist7
      Participant

      Great read! Pace is on target, flowed well… Enjoyed listening to this one!

    • #83635
      Jaljr
      Participant

      Listened through a couple of time. Hard to find anything not to like.

  • #83583
    Earthbul
    Participant

    Thoughts on recording quality ? Was also wondering if the music mix is adequate ?
    Thanks in advance

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #84292
      ShellyMadison
      Participant

      Your voice is clear and forward. Recording sounds well recorded and mastered. I think the music should be louder to sound more cohesive. Currently being lost in the background (at least on my computer speakers)

  • #83526
    Earthbul
    Participant

    Narration read. Far from perfect. Thoughts ?

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
Viewing 3,184 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.