Feedback Forum

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #15468
    David Goldberg
    Edge Studio Staff

    Hi! Upload your recordings, and get feedback from your peers!

Viewing 3,169 reply threads
  • Author
    Replies
  • #84553
    Provocaleric
    Participant

    Nice Erik, I think your sound definitely has marketability! I like your thick sound and my only real criticism would be to do more face and mouth stretching, I can hear some binding up at the end of some of those thick phrases, but really nice job! Please feel free to critique me, thanks!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
  • #84534
    Provocaleric
    Participant

    Hello fellow Voice artists! My name is Eric and I would appreciate some honest criticism about this recording. I would be happy to evaluate you as well, thank you for taking the time. One Vanderbilt Observation Deck Audio Simulation. Hello, and welcome to the audio simulation of the One Vanderbilt Observation Deck. Please adjust your audio volume to a level that best represents my voice at a normal speaking volume to a person standing next to you. This will calibrate your headphone level. Please do not adjust your audio volume again over the course of the simulation. Thank you.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #84707
      Michele Martin
      Participant

      Hi Eric- This is my first time on this forum providing feedback, so please bear with me if this comment is not in the right place. It’s intended to be feedback on the practice file of One Vanderbilt OB deck. I really enjoyed your read and find your voice very pleasant to listen to, and also very professional-sounding (if that’s a thing- ha). Aside from the micro-pauses someone else mentioned, the only other thing that caught my attention was the “Hello!” at the beginning of the piece. It sounded a touch like “Hullo” and I thought the pronunciation might be tweaked a bit more in the “Hello” (like in chelo) direction. Not sure if that’s a subjective thing, or a correct/incorrect thing, so disregard my comment if it’s just a personal taste issue. Nice sound!!
      Michele

    • #84598
      Tim Kraft
      Participant

      Hi Eric – Overall I think this is a good read, but gets a little “pause-y” in the middle. You do: “a level that best represents my voice (pause) at a normal speaking volume (pause) to a person standing next to you”. Personally I’d go straight through that, no micropauses. I often find that blowing through commas in a script makes it sound less choppy. Conversely adding the pause sounds hesitant and less conversational.

      A good match for your sound though…friendly, enthusiastic and clear, all very applicable to instructional reads. Nice job !

  • #84528
    leanaguzman
    Participant

    Hey everybody! I’m working on some narration scripts/explainer videos (three attached) and would love some general feedback. Thank you!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #84533
      Provocaleric
      Participant

      Hello Leana,
      I’m pretty new to this but I like the sound of your voice! you have a very clear and soothing sound the only negative I would have might be I hear to many mouth noises, I’m sure its just a de click kind of thing, Otherwise I would hire you, good luck!

  • #84526
    Earthbul
    Participant

    Primary Freight practice read
    Any and all comments welcomed and appreciated

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #84536
      Provocaleric
      Participant

      Hello Earthbul,
      nice work. I think your voice has real authenticity and I imagined you being apart of the railway industry! The only criticism would be to maybe hydrate a little more, your mouth sounds a little cottony, other than that I’m sure I’ll be hearing you about, good luck!

      • #84550
        Earthbul
        Participant

        I agree 110% with the “cottony” sound. I’ll hydrate more while recording.
        Btw I listened to your read and really enjoyed it.

  • #84516
    Talia Hankin
    Participant

    Hello! Attached below are two narration reads (both corp. explainer). I would appreciate any and all feedback you may have. Thank you!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
  • #84499
    Erik B
    Participant

    Hi everybody, here is a commercial practice read. I would appreciate any feedback in regards to technique and sound quality. Thank you.

    Waterpik

    If you floss you know what a two-handed tug of war feels like. Which is why we at Waterpik are introducing the Flosser. At a speed of 10,000 gentle strokes per minute, its nylon tip effectively removes plaque above and below the gumline. Making it a fast, easy and more convenient way to keep gums their healthiest, and teeth their cleanest. With no strings attached.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #84557
      Earthbul
      Participant

      I like your take on this although I feel your delivery is a tad too harsh.
      I also hear a bit of mouth noise. All that being said I really like the sound of your voice.
      Look forward to hearing a bit more from you.

  • #84479
    odellodim
    Participant

    Hi All. Here are reads from 3 different scripts. I welcome and appreciate any feedback you are able to offer. Thank you.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
  • #84477
    e4gaa
    Participant

    Hi, very first foray into the VO world. Any feedback on this bank internet audio piece would be appreciated
    Thanks

    Do you use your debit or credit card to pay for things online?
    We’re making some changes to protect you from fraud.
    In line with Payment Services regulations, in the next few weeks, you may be asked to confirm your online card payments more often.
    (Just so we know it’s you…)

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #84498
      Erik B
      Participant

      Hi e4gaa, the authoritative tone in your voice is solid, but perhaps add a smile in the last line. Just because the tone for a read is authoritative, it doesn’t mean it cannot be friendly at certain sections. Also the pacing of your read was very good. Good job.

  • #84473
    Logan DFD
    Participant

    I need some feedback before another coaching session, specifically about Micropauses and Glottal Stops, as well as not reading too fast. Just need to work that stuff out. Thanks!

    Atlanta Bread Company

    When you think of Atlanta Bread Company, don’t just think ‘bread’.
    Think of an entire breakfast menu – fresh-baked pastries, hot breakfast sandwiches and specialty coffees.
    Think of our Cafe with savory sandwiches, daily soups and crisp salads.
    And don’t forget…we can cater your next special event or meeting!
    Atlanta Bread Company – more than just bread.

    A1 Steak Sauce

    With steak, you want to make every bite count.
    That’s why we use A-1 Steak Sauce.
    A-1 brings out every single bite of steak, or even hamburger.
    Mmmmm, delicious.
    For me, there’s only one steak sauce, A-1.
    Because A-1 has all the taste that makes every bite count.

    Special K Red Berries

    Putting strawberries in cereal wasn’t our idea.
    Putting them in the box was.
    With slices of real strawberries and crunchy sweet flakes, looking good never tasted so good.
    Special K Red Berries.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #84597
      Tim Kraft
      Participant

      He there. I definitely don’t think these are too fast. If that’s been a problem in the past, you’ve improved! Micropauses help bring you to more conversational speed, and I think that’s best shown in the A1 read. Also think A1 is the best read overall: most conversational and natural, and you keep up the energy through the last line. On special K and Atlanta Bread, the last line sorta trails off.

      Not hearing any glottal stops, but I never really developed an ear for them in US English :-/ I hear them in British English all the time (they’re very obvious), but if you’ve had issues in the past I’d never know it.

      Nice reads all around!

  • #84466
    Jhaman
    Participant

    Got two reads of the same script. Wondering about general thoughts and which you like more. Trying to be conversational and clear.

    Beavers Voice Over Script: “The beavers build their lodge out of intertangled twigs and sticks; as freezing weather nears, they plaster their lodge with mud, making a concrete layer that no predator can break through. During the early nineteenth century, the beavers pelt was the single most valuable commodity; the pelt was used for robes, coats, clothing trims, and top hats.”

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #84470
      Earthbul
      Participant

      I enjoyed the 2nd read. Flowed much more smoothly. Maybe a little over enunciated in some spots but definitely conversational.

Viewing 3,169 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.