Feedback Forum

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #15468
    David Goldberg
    Edge Studio Staff

    Hi! Upload your recordings, and get feedback from your peers!

Viewing 3,181 reply threads
  • Author
    Replies
  • #60964
    mrgenadry
    Participant

    Hi there, folks. My first ever recording post. Let me know what you think. Have a great 2021!

    Benjamin Moore – “Love”

    This may sound trite, or cliche.
    And maybe if we were talking about chocolate and flowers, it would be.
    But we’re talking about paint, so hear us out.
    Love is an amazing thing. It has the power to change everything.
    A love of craft can turn work and labor into an act of creative expression.
    Love can make you see past obvious flaws in a facade, to the beauty underneath.
    Love can turn a pair of hands into a set of tools.
    Love can turn pigment and polymers into magical liquid.
    Love can turn a house into a home.
    And turn a bunch of homes into a community.
    Love can transform. And when you want your love to transform a home…
    There is no other paint than Benjamin Moore.

    • This reply was modified 4 years, 1 month ago by mrgenadry.
    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #61024
      John Trape
      Participant

      Hi MrGenadry! I thoroughly enjoyed listening to your recording and then absorbing Mary’s and Toque’s observations. A particularly useful exercise for me, being new to the game, so to speak. I felt that you had really spent time interpreting the script, and that you knew exactly how you wished to connect with your intended audience. You should be pretty pleased!

      Kind regards,

      John

    • #61013
      mkell755
      Participant

      Hi MrGenadry! Welcome to the forum! This is a good genre for you. You have a nice warm voice and good enunciation. I liked the pauses throughout too, helps the listener consider what is being said. I agree with Toque in that the word “love” because it repeated so many times might be good to vary up in tone now and then. Overall really good. keep up the good work!

      Mary

    • #60977
      Toque
      Participant

      Hi there! You have a good voice for this kind of read! Audio quality sounded fine to me. Just a few other comments: 1) If the script says “talking, and not “talkin'”, you may want to consider fully pronouncing it. Of course it’s hard to say without any direction added to the script.2) Because the word “Love” is repeated a number of times, you may want to consider some slight variation in how each is delivered. I believe you made a change for the last one, but the others sounded very similar. 3) In the second-last line, the pause between the words “transform” and “And” feels overly long. Great work! Hope this helps. Toque

  • #60955
    chas82
    Participant

    Happy & Safe New Year to all !! It’s been a little while but now I’m back in the saddle. My current focus is on whiskey Commercials. I’m starting with two I found for Jack Daniel’s. Still working on creating the recording space but any and all feedback appreciated.

    JD #1
    In Lynchburg, Tennessee, you can park in the middle of the road to talk with a neighbor about taxes or the weather. You can pick enough wild blackberries to fill a tin bucket. And you can see a distillery where Jack Daniel made whiskey way back in 1866. We still make it in a slow, deliberate fashion, much as he did. One sip, and you’ll be glad to know we don’t ever plan to stop. Jack Daniel’s … smooth sippin’ Tennessee whiskey.

    JD#2
    Giving the right gift is easy. Just follow these simple steps.
    First, pick up a bottle of Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Whiskey.
    Now, the size ya choose depends on who it’s for. Say, your boss, a friend or a brother.
    Second, get some wrapping paper and ribbon. It’s kinda like wrappin’ a tennis racket. They’re gonna know what it is, but that’s part of the charm.
    And last, and most important, step three. Be there when they open it.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #61014
      mkell755
      Participant

      Hi Chas – really nice! I like the deep rasp and range in your voice, it is perfect for a whiskey commercial. Nice variation in tone throughout for both scripts and really nice pacing and enunciation too. Good smile in your voice. Good job!

      Mary

    • #60986
      Toque
      Participant

      Hi Chas. Script #1 was great. The only thing I noted was (and this may just be my ears) but in the first 2 seconds of the recording it kinda sounded like it started at one volume and then jumped up to something a tad louder? Script # 2 sounded great. Whisky ads area great choice for your voice. Toque

      • #60995
        chas82
        Participant

        Thanks Toque. You have a fine ear. I clipped the first 2 seconds and pasted in a re-do. Thought I had a good match but apparently not that good. Appreciate your feedback. – Chas

  • #60949
    SuperLuke
    Participant

    Good to be back everyone and happy New Year! I’ve got a new microphone and was wondering how my performance and recording quality are. I’m really trying to eliminate the unwanted humming and hissing from my previous performances.

    All feedback welcome

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #61016
      mkell755
      Participant

      Hi Luke! I too am having a hard time hearing almost anything, except a few words that are louder than the others now and then, with volume on max. Can you try re-recording and reloading?

      Mary

      • #61104
        SuperLuke
        Participant

        Yes, I can resubmit this recording. Sorry if you can’t hear anything, neither could I. It’s the microphones positioning and whether I was super close vs. farther away. I’ll fix that and resubmit.
        Thanks for the comments, I appreciate it.

    • #60988
      Toque
      Participant

      Hi Luke. The recording volume is super-low. I can barely hear that there’s someone talking. Toque

      • #61110
        SuperLuke
        Participant

        Hey guys! Sorry the volume was so low in my previous practice demo. Here is a fresh version of it that I recorded with the AT2020 at another angle. All feedback is appreciated.

        Attachments:
        You must be logged in to view attached files.
  • #60932
    burdahgirl
    Participant

    Practice Script from the Edge Library. I’d love any feedback, THANKS!

    American Express
    Do you know me? Probably not. In my business, recognition is always important, but when I’m buying goods online I prefer a little privacy. With Private Payments from American Express, I get the security of a unique number created for each business transaction I make. Because my private information is my business, and American Express keeps it that way.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #61003
      mkell755
      Participant

      Hi Burdagirl, very good! The variation in tone and the pacing were great. It sounded very natural and authentic for this script. I liked the emphasis on Private Payments as it appears to me like it’s the highlighted product / point of the commercial. Very good job!

      Mary

    • #60982
      Erik B
      Participant

      Hi Burdahgirl. The pacing of your read was very good. I noticed the overemphasis on “private payments”. To help “get out of your head” step away from the mic, before reading a sentence with a troublesome word or words, raise your arms to your side and take two deep breathes, then go back to the mic and deliver the line. Overall good job.

    • #60963
      mrgenadry
      Participant

      Really good read! One thing that’s helped me with commercial copy is to imagine the script as the middle of the conversation, not the beginning. Either you’re telling someone something they don’t know, or they’ve just told you something with which you disagree. This can elevate your excitement and increase the energy of the read.

      In this case, I would imagine that you’re making small talk with a new client about a recent experience with identity theft. They’ve heard of Private Payments, but they thought it sounded like BS. So the question “Do you know me?” can be a little more authoritative; you both already know the answer is no. Then, accent the contrast: “In my BUSINESS, recognition is always important.” Changing that opening motivation might help you keep the urgency up throughout the read.

      Best of luck!

    • #60943
      SuperLuke
      Participant

      Good performance and recording quality. It can get better though. When you say “private payments”, I hear you stepping out of character, forcing the “P” sound. hope this was a helpful critique

      • #60944
        burdahgirl
        Participant

        Thanks, that is helpful. I struggle so hard with my plosive ‘p’s and was attempting to not have them pop so much. But I totally agree they sound weird. Thanks for the critique!

  • #60917
    mkell755
    Participant

    Hello all! Here is a recording (done on my phone) for any and all feedback. Let me know what you think. Thank you!!

    Mary

    Shelly’s Interiors
    Are there times when you feel like you live in a boring, grey box? Well, it’s time to break out of the crypt with a fresh coat of paint and interior decorating services from Shelly’s Interiors!

    Within hours, your home will be transformed to reflect your tastes. Don’t know what your taste is? No problem. Shelly’s Interiors has a wide array of styles in their portfolio to choose from, including Modern Chic, Urban Elegance, and Rural Escape.

    To get a preview, visit Shelleysinteriors.com. From there you can browse styles, then give us a call at 555-5455 or send us an email from the website to set up a consultation. Shelly’s Interiors – turning houses into homes since 1990.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #60954
      rogue1
      Participant

      Hi Mary, there’s a real warmth to your voice which I find very appealing. Continue to expand upon that lovely sincerity by perhaps leaning into an even more conversational in your delivery (more like a chat with a friend than a read from a script—-a naturalness I’m working to perfect myself). As others mentioned, I do hear a technical hum in the background, but a solid read! Definitely have the perfect aural temperament for the client.

      • #61001
        mkell755
        Participant

        Hi Rogue1, thanks for your feedback! Yes, I am definitely working on making the performance sound more conversational, will continue to work on that. Thanks again!

        Mary

    • #60930
      burdahgirl
      Participant

      Hey Mary! I haven’t been on the forum for a few weeks – you are CRUSHING the smile in the voice! Congrats!!

      • #60998
        mkell755
        Participant

        Hi Burdahgirl, thank you for your feedback! I’m glad you can tell a difference!! Progress – YEAH! 🙂

        Mary

      • #60945
        SuperLuke
        Participant

        Hi Mary, aside from the ringing sound by your phone, you were able to record yourself pretty good. But I think you can perform better than that. Let the smile be in your voice and don’t force anything in or hold you back from creating the perfect performance

        • #60997
          mkell755
          Participant

          Thanks for the feedback SuperLuke! Yes, I’m starting to work on the setup in my studio, I never noticed the buzzing / humming of the fan on my computer until I started voiceover! I will continue to work on the smile in my voice and pushing the performance more, just trying to not cross the line of ridiculousness! Sounds like I have a ways to go 🙂 Thank you!

          Mary

  • #60906
    ChristyPark
    Participant

    Hello all!

    I’d love feedback on this Physical Therapy VO audition. There are 60 1-2 min spots like this and it would be super to contribute! I recorded in my newly tech approved in home booth. Thanks for your insight.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #60931
      burdahgirl
      Participant

      Hey Christy! Great voice, I agree with Mary, you have an awesome voice for this genre. The setup sounded good, although there was a little hum through my headphones. I don’t know enough about sound to know if it was an issue on my end, though! The read was fantastic, and I could absolutely imagine doing PT with that recording. Question: is the breathing instructive in the read? Like something the patient should do with you? The breathing was very noticeable so I thought maybe it was meant to be included. If it is not instructive, I might silence some of them, especially the one at the beginning. I’m a noob, so take all of that with a grain of salt!

      • #60965
        ChristyPark
        Participant

        Thanks so much, I took the breaths out before submitting. I appreciate this feedback!

    • #60912
      mkell755
      Participant

      Hi Christy, you have a great voice for this genre. It sounded calm and reassuring. I’m not fully set up yet with my studio but the sound quality sounds good on my end. Good job!

      Mary

      • #60946
        SuperLuke
        Participant

        Good recording quality. I like your voice in the performance. I don’t know what the director of the audition wants. But you would do well in this field as a physical therapist

  • #60904
    svenbot5000
    Participant

    Howdy ya’ll! Back at it again, I just wanted to read this one because it looked stupid. I’d love any feedback!

    Uncle

    I’m going to let you kids in a little secret, I’m not really your Uncle i killed him and stuffed him under the floorboards HA HA HA HA HA HA Ehh I’m just kidding I’m, I’m probably your Uncle

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #60985
      Erik B
      Participant

      Howdy Svenbot, I liked the read, you had the sinister tone down. The only suggestion I have is to not rush it. Good job.

    • #60958
      rogue1
      Participant

      Hi Svenbot, Wow, you’ve definitely got character to spare! If I were to suggest any tweaking it would be to let your read breathe a bit, no reason to rush, let the listener enjoy your voice. Specifically, perhaps a slight pause after “I’m going to let you kids in on a little secret” to build the tension, and definitely a shade more pause on your comic timing before you stick that (killer) ending. Great work!

    • #60913
      mkell755
      Participant

      Hi Svenbot – that was really creepy good! I liked the character voice, very convincing! I was chuckling on that one. Good job!

      Mary

      • #60947
        SuperLuke
        Participant

        If you’re going for the suspense-thriller/ batman vs. the joker genre, you’ve got a good thing going.

  • #60895
    John Trape
    Participant

    Good Afternoon and Happy New Year everyone! This is the first recording that I have submitted to the Feedback Forum and I would very much appreciate your feedback. The script is drawn from the Edge Practice Script Library.

    Thank you,

    John

    John Trapé

    Albert Einstein

    Albert Einstein was a genius, and one of the greatest physicists of all time. His famous Theories of Relativity, which describe the relationship between mass and energy, and between space and time, were published in 1905 and 1916. Einstein was born of Jewish parents in Ulm, Germany. He spent many years in Switzerland, becoming a Swiss citizen in 1901, and gaining his Doctor of Philosophy degree in 1905 from Zurich University. It was while employed as a patent clerk in Berne that he published his first Theory of Relativity. This contained his famous equation: E=mc2, which explains the relationship between mass and energy.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #60914
      mkell755
      Participant

      Hi John, first of all welcome! That was very nice. Your voice sounds really good for this genre. You enunciation is very clear and your voice is nice and warm, and the pacing was great too. I’m getting the Terrence Stamp impression from your voice (actor in “Yes Man” and many other movies) – that is a compliment! The only tiny critique I could find is the pronunciation of the word “clerk” sounded like “clark” to me, small thing. Keep up the good work!

      Mary

      • #60928
        John Trape
        Participant

        Hi Mary,

        Thank you very much for your feedback. Following my first practice session with Art, he told me to focus on enunciation, to avoid suppressing words, and to pay attention to pacing. So, your comments are really encouraging. And, yes, I will need to be careful about my pronunciation.

        Kind regards,

        John

        • #60948
          SuperLuke
          Participant

          Wow! This is a great performance/ narration performance.

        • #61018
          John Trape
          Participant

          Hi Luke,

          Thank you very much for your encouragement.

          Kind regards,

          John

  • #60888
    monibr16
    Participant

    Hey everyone! I gave my last commercial another try with the feedback given. More enthusiasm being the main adjustment. Please let me know how I did! Thank you.

    Trendi.com
    Trendi.com. It’s the #1 shopping site for top name brands at up to 75% off. Great style, great value and everything ships free. Trendi.com. Everything you love, for less.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #61015
      kfvoice
      Participant

      monibr16 — Nice job! I could hear the difference and improvement from your last read. Keep it up!

    • #60915
      mkell755
      Participant

      Hi Monibr16, really nice! Great enthusiasm and energy, sounds great! I believe I heard the previous version and this one is much improved. Good job!

      Mary

      • #61002
        monibr16
        Participant

        Thank you so much for taking another listen/feedback Mary!

        • #61057
          mkell755
          Participant

          Sure thing! 🙂

  • #60884
    mkell755
    Participant

    Hello all! Here is a recording for any and all feedback. Let me know what you think! Thanks,

    Mary

    Chico’s
    Chico’s was founded in 1983 as a small boutique selling Mexican folk art on Sanibel Island in Florida. Then one day, our founders discovered the sweater that made literally everyone look fabulous. They then quickly pivoted the business, and retail was never the same. Now there are over 600 Chico’s boutiques nationwide.

    From our exclusive, private-label designs to our most amazing personal service, Chico’s is truly a unique retail environment. When you walk into any Chico’s store, you can depend upon the sales staff to coordinate, accessorize, and help you build a wardrobe to suit your needs. We’re moving fast, but not without you. Get yourself to Chico’s!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #60929
      John Trape
      Participant

      Hi Mary,

      I thoroughly enjoyed listening to your recording. Among the tips that I will take away are your enthusiasm, conversational tone, and relaxed voice. I felt that I was not being rushed through a script. In fact, I forgot that I was listening to a script. Rather, by giving me the time to absorb the story of Chico’s, you were piquing my interest in the company.

      Kind regards,

      John

      • #61005
        mkell755
        Participant

        Hi John, thanks for the feedback! I’m working on sounding authentic for the script and conversational, and keeping things flowing but not too slow or too fast, so thanks again for your comments!

        Mary

    • #60908
      Robert Broussard
      Participant

      Mary,

      That was good. I think the pace could have been a little faster. The last was sentence really was natural and flowing. Keep up the good work.

      • #60909
        mkell755
        Participant

        Thanks for the feedback Robert! I will work on the pacing for this one, and glad the last sentence flowed. Thanks!

        Mary

    • #60903
      svenbot5000
      Participant

      Hi Mary! Good read! I liked the last sentence, I could really hear the enthusiasm there. I think you could add that flair to the earlier parts as well.

      • #60910
        mkell755
        Participant

        Thanks for the feedback Svenbot! Glad you could hear the enthusiasm, and I will try to add it in earlier too. Thanks!

        Mary

    • #60900
      Erik B
      Participant

      Hi Mary, I liked the pacing of your read. Also you hit key words very well. In addition I like how you differentiated “coordinate, accesorize, and help” . The only critique I have is, I heard a pause in the first sentence of the second paragraph,”private label designs to our”. But overall you did a good job.

      • #60911
        mkell755
        Participant

        Hi Erik, thanks for your feedback! I listened again to hear that pause and I see what you mean. This one could use a little more practice. Thank you!

        Mary

Viewing 3,181 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.