Feedback Forum

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #15468
    David Goldberg
    Edge Studio Staff

    Hi! Upload your recordings, and get feedback from your peers!

Viewing 3,183 reply threads
  • Author
    Replies
  • #64408
    jmtarleton
    Participant

    Hello kind folks! Uploading a few takes of commercial reads I’m working on. I really appreciate the time and any feedback you have.

    All the best,

    John

    PSA ON ENVIRONMENT

    A key to reducing waste is to shop wisely and purchase only what you need

    You can also buy household products with less packaging

    And when it comes to food opt for loose produce

    So reduce, then recycle the rest

    The more you know

    Aspen

    At the gate the everyday vanishes

    Here your thoughts are a little clearer

    Your appetite for life a little sharper

    This mountain, as captivating under summer flowers as it is under snow

    Aspen is a one-of-a-kind resort

    Unhurried Carefree And cozy like an Alpine Village under a starry night

    Ambien

    There is a rhythm to life

    We sleep at night and wake in the morning

    It’s the sleep cycle that helps keep us in a healthy balance

    But for millions of Americans sleep doesn’t always come easily

    For them there’s AMBIEN

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #64413
      tomnunes
      Participant

      Hi, John. Some nice reads here. Words are clear. For the most part, you avoided unnecessary pauses. The energy in your read is great for the PSA. You had a similar energy or tone for Aspen and Ambient, which, in my opinion, calls for a calmer energy. Aspen feels like it calls for an easy, relaxed, dreamy, leave your troubles at the door and relax tone. If you haven’t, find a person you’re talking to. What do you want them to feel? Where are you while saying this. Paint the picture for them. The line “This mountain, as captivating…” has unique punctuation. It’s kind of like “This mountain (man-oh-man) as captivating…

      For Ambien, this may be just my interpretation, but an ad that promotes sleep should sound calming and relaxing. There’s an interesting arc to the city you can play with more. 1) this is nice. 2) this is nice. 3) and this is nice. 4) this is bad, 5) but this will make it good.

      If you are also looking for feedback on sound quality, the audio has a lot of echo. You’ll have to treat your recording space. Are you working with anyone to help with that?

      Thanks for sharing, John.

  • #64404
    RYoung
    Participant

    This was taken from the script of a movie about Columbus. Trying or practicing narration to go along with a storyboard! Any thoughts are welcome. Oh and this is the first part thats why it ends so abruptly, Thanks.

    All sit beside her. TREASURER SANCHEZ takes a document
    and starts to read aloud.

    On screen the words: GRANADA – SPAIN – 1500

    SANCHEZ
    Your Majesty would wish to know the true facts concerning the island of
    Hispanola, our first settlement in the New World, and the activities
    there of your servant, Christopher Columbus, Admiral of the Ocean Sea,
    Governor of that Island. You will remember with what hopes and promises
    he beguiled us — the truth is that he now presides over a state
    of chaos, degradation and madness beyond imagining.

    SANCHEZ punctuates each word carefully.

    SANCHEZ
    From the beginning, Columbus proved himself incapable of managing the
    affairs of the island. He appointed his brothers to important positions,
    at once injuring the pride and dignity of the nobles who had gone
    with him. He promised to build a city, the City of Isabel, named
    after Your Majesty. What he actually built was nothing but a
    collection of huts, and that in the wrong place, for all of it was
    easily swept away by rain and mud. Is that not so, Brother Buyl?

    The PRIEST nods.

    BROTHER BUYL
    Yes, Your Honor.

    SANCHEZ
    He promised gold. Not finding the
    easy quantities he promised,
    Columbus commanded each Indian to
    pay an annual tribute. Most being
    unable to, they were barbarously
    punished, against the express wish
    of Your Christian Majesties…

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
  • #64382
    Jeff Guerrette
    Participant

    Hello, My name is Jeff, I attached a couple of scrips I recorded for homework. Look forward to your feedback.

    Thanks.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #64395
      eglover177
      Participant

      I think you sound great i heard i flaw the way you pronounced Wall it sounded like war

      • #64425
        NoreenQuadir
        Participant

        These sound great. I would add more energy towards the end especially with the call to action.

  • #64379
    JasonCawley
    Participant

    Hey looking for some feedback. Thank you guys.


    Beginner paddle boarders should choose a wider, longer and thicker board. This will offer the greatest stability to learn the paddle board basics on a flat body of water. As you gain experience, you can progress to a smaller paddle board. The most common board shape for beginners is an All-Around paddle board. However, there are a few different types and shapes of paddle boards to consider.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #64394
      ritadebur
      Participant

      I liked the pace and clarity of the words. Very natural- the only thing I thought was the word ‘however’ was a little rushed without enough of a pause.

      • #64426
        NoreenQuadir
        Participant

        This is great – clear and easy to follow/understand!

  • #64375
    jay.triggs
    Participant

    Good Evening everyone, I wanted to get some feedback on a recording I did this week for Narration. Thanks in advance.

    Cheers!

    As the tide covers the dock with just an inch or two of water these Tiger Sharks are making their move. Nurse sharks can sometimes propel themselves onto docks when going after scraps of fish. It’s a learned behavior, and evidence that sharks may come on land to feed. Is that also what these sharks are attempting to do?

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #64378
      JasonCawley
      Participant

      Hello Jay,

      Good stuff, I would just try to get a little more variance in the pitch to keep it engaging throughout.

  • #64371
    ritadebur
    Participant

    My first recording – thought id try a meditation one… any feedback would be appreciated! Thank you

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #64374
      Tina
      Participant

      That was great! Good job for your first time. You definitely got the relaxing vibe down and your natural delivery has nice pacing to it. The only thing I noticed was the words “you will” in the sentence “during this breathing medication, you will focus on your breath” sound rushed together so I’d just enunciate that clearer.

  • #64359

    Hey Guys!

    Here are the 3 scripts i recorded for homework for my coach. im working on my glottals and trying to use more range in my voice. Feedback is welcomed.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #64403
      RYoung
      Participant

      Excellent natural style delivery, the Ben and Jerry’s one I would just say to go deeper into the character of the fairy? Nice work and keep it up!

    • #64370
      ritadebur
      Participant

      Total newbie so not sure how much my opinion counts – but i liked your Ben &B Jerry’s one the best – your voice suited the style and I thought it sounded upbeat, convincing and personal.

  • #64345
    mkell755
    Participant

    Hello all! I’m looking for any and all feedback here – same script read 2 slightly different ways. Which do you like better and why? Thanks!

    Mary

    HGTV – Designer Challenge
    One Room in desperate need of a makeover. Three possible solutions. Which would you choose? Designer’s Challenge. Coming up Next. Only on HGTV.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #64367
      Robert Broussard
      Participant

      Good job Mary on both, but I like #2 better.

      • #64385
        mkell755
        Participant

        Thanks for the feedback Robert! Appreciate it.

        Mary

        • #64391
          irvj
          Participant

          Both were good reads but I prefer #2 as it sounded a bit more natural and conversational.

    • #64358
      John Trape
      Participant

      Hi Mary,

      I thoroughly enjoyed listening to both readings, but I felt that the second reading was the one that seemed the more natural, the more convincing. It was almost as if you were addressing an audience that you could actually see. Sounds a little bizarre, I am sure, but it seemed that there was more of a connection between you and an audience in your second reading and that that translated into a more natural flow, with emphasis falling where your instincts told you, and suggestion of a script in your hands pushed to one side.

      Thank you for sharing.

      John

      • #64386
        mkell755
        Participant

        Thanks for the feedback John! I tried this one many times before picking the top two. Super short script but so many ways to read it. Trying to find the line of appropriate energy, enthusiasm and naturalness for this type of script without being too over the top. Thanks again!

        mary

  • #64338
    Dante M.
    Participant

    Good evening everyone, I have three more scripts that I’m interested in sharing! As always, I appreciate extreme criticism!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #64458
      Robert Broussard
      Participant

      Good job Dante, I agree 1 & 3 were more natural. Good voice on all.

    • #64392
      irvj
      Participant

      1 & 3 you had more fun with whereas 2 was stiff and slightly choppy. It sounded as if you were reading. But you’re on the right track. Keep it up!

    • #64349
      mkell755
      Participant

      Hi Dante, very nice! I really like your nice deep voice and warm delivery – great clarity and pacing. I like scripts 1 and 3 best for you. The second script felt more like you were reading to me, not sure why that was exactly, maybe just more emphasized enunciation than the other two? The other two sounded more natural and with good inflection levels. Keep up the good work!

      Mary

    • #64348
      RYoung
      Participant

      I believe the volume was loud on my end in listening to your recording. You can always normalize down to correct that unless you were redlining when recording. Otherwise your delivery is great, I would just back off on the mic slightly to avoid too many mouth noises, unless that was the volume issue? Ancient mysteries was a little too stiff, so relax maybe and try a more conversational delivery? Hope that helps and good luck!

    • #64344
      Dante M.
      Participant

      I’m not sure why I’m unable to edit my post, but I just wanted to say that my audio files were louder, but for some reason they uploaded rather quietly.

  • #64324
    RYoung
    Participant

    All comments most welcome!
    The Chevy Silverado Trail Boss
    When you have a two inch lift…
    When you have Goodyear Duratrack tires…
    When you have Rancho shocks…and an integrated dual exhaust…
    When you have all that…
    The last thing you’ll need…is a road…
    The Chevy Silverado Trail Boss…
    Ready to off-road…right from the factory.
    Chevy….find new roads…

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #64342
      Dante M.
      Participant

      You have a wonderful voice for this type of script. I would just slow it down slightly and obey the ellipses more , as that would further increase the synergy you have with the read. You highlighted the words appropriately.

    • #64336
      Tina
      Participant

      Great read and nice pacing. The only suggestion I have is going down in pitch on the word factory. Right now it goes up and I think you want it more of a statement.

    • #64326
      Robert Broussard
      Participant

      Good read, good pacing and tone!

Viewing 3,183 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.