Feedback Forum

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #15468
    David Goldberg
    Edge Studio Staff

    Hi! Upload your recordings, and get feedback from your peers!

Viewing 3,171 reply threads
  • Author
    Replies
  • #65016
    monibr16
    Participant

    Hello everyone,
    Looking for feedback on my commercial practice. Lead ins, and everything, also if the mic sounds “too hot”. Thank you!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #65020
      SuperLuke
      Participant

      You do a great job with the enthusiasm in your voice, advertising Six flags! At the end, I think there could be more enthusiasm in the word “yes”.

      • #65040
        monibr16
        Participant

        Thank you Luke!

        • #65386
          timmurphy306
          Participant

          Loved listening to this! Enthusiasm, pacing, and the emphasis on the right phrases, like “…paint the cat” were superb. I didn’t notice anything “hot” about your mic. If I had to nitpick, I would agree with SuperLuke that maybe a little more emphasis on the last “YES!” would really end things on a high note. Great work!

  • #64988
    mkell755
    Participant

    Hi everyone! Looking for any and all feedback to this script. Working on getting the sound levels right, and sounding conversational. I did this one awhile back and hopefully this one is improved. Let me know what you think. Thank you!

    Mary

    Sears Carpets
    OH! Welcome to my commercial. I just want to tell you about what a great experience I had buying new carpet from Sears. Well, I went to Sears and found that DuPont no-stain carpets were on sale through Saturday. They also offered free installation guaranteed. If you want one of America’s premiere carpet brands, just go to Sears. It’s DuPont Stainless in hundreds of colors and textures, on sale through Saturday, at Sears.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #65563
      Eliz_10
      Participant

      Hello Mkell755,
      I put this in the wrong place the other day so you may not have seen it.
      Enjoyed listening to your Sears carpet commercial. Your tone of voice and delivery are very smooth and soothing to the ear. I think you emphasized all the right words and gave a convincing reason to shop at Sears.

      Keep up the good work.
      Elizabeth

      • #65691
        mkell755
        Participant

        Thanks for the feedback Elizabeth! I saw your feedback, and thank you! Working to sound more conversational and convincing, so thank you for that! Thanks again for takign the time to write your comments twice – they don’t always post to the right place 🙂

        Mary

    • #65021
      SuperLuke
      Participant

      It’s a good performance. And I think you can improve on the performance so that you sound at your best

      • #65029
        mkell755
        Participant

        Thanks for the feedback SuperLuke! I will work on this one a bit more – there is always room for improvement! 🙂

        Mary

    • #64990
      Robert Broussard
      Participant

      Mary,

      I think your loudness of recording is about right. Your read was easy to listen to and conversational. Good Job. I miss having sears here in WF.

      • #65028
        mkell755
        Participant

        Thanks for the feedback Robert! Glad the recording level is sounding ok, and that it’s a little more conversational. Sears was an institution for sure!

        Mary

  • #64983
    JohnFinn
    Participant

    Hello- practice reads here, any feedback and suggestion are welcome. All reads are from the Edge Studio script library. Thank you!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #65035
      mkell755
      Participant

      Hi John, good reads! I really like the tone of your voice and it seems very well suited for these genres.
      Script 1: Good tone and pace. There were parts that sounded like you were reading vs. performing such as “…across the Golden Gate bridge” , otherwise really nice and informative.
      Script 2: Great tone and delivery for this type of medical script.
      Script 3: Good variation in your tone for the subject
      Good job! Keep it up.

      Mary

  • #64976
    artyom123
    Participant

    Hello all, still working on my emotion connection – story telling. Would love feedback on my read of this script:

    One of the biggest threats to my company’s operations was the way we managed risk. Our risk management system was spread over multiple platforms, which caused a lot of information gaps and siloed data and communications among our teams. Then Risk and Compliance came in. By relying on their expertise, our risk management system became an asset instead of a source of complexity.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #65036
      mkell755
      Participant

      Hi Artyom, good read! I like the tone and clarity of your voice. It did seem a bit fast overall, you might try tiny micropauses at the end of sentences to let the listener catch up to what you are telling them. Good job!

      Mary

    • #65002
      JohnFinn
      Participant

      Hello- besides the missing phrase, a nice job getting emotion added in there with higher and lower pitched words/phrases. Keep an eye on pace, some phrases were faster than others. Nice job overall!

    • #64978
      artyom123
      Participant

      just realized I might have missed a phrase, still looking for feedback =)

  • #64970
    sarahtranchina
    Participant

    Working on longer form copy. Would love any and all feedback. Thanks!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #65544
      waninick
      Participant

      Hi Sarah,

      Vocalizing groupings of items is an art form in itself.
      And this script has lots of lists, even some that are nested.

      Teach you the cure for writer’s block
      the recipe for lobster ravioli
      beef wellington
      How to lead a company
      train your dog
      pick a paint color
      a perfect song
      a new career

      Using pitch, inflection, and pacing can make the group members more obvious.

      I say all that to say that in at least one place, an element is separated from the
      rest of its list. ‘Pick a paint color’ seems to be haning on its own, leaving
      ‘a perfect song’ with no linkage or context. Were you to transition into ‘a perfect
      song’ the way you transition into ‘a new career’, the entire group comes together
      under the group ‘pick’.

      Full disclosure: I am not a director. But a good one would help you understand
      how to use pitch and pacing and tempo to make these kinds of lists of lists
      coherent and engaging at the same time. (OMT, be mindful of your P’s…!)
      You have an absolutely wonderful, clear, articulate voice. And I look forward
      very much to hearing more from you.

      TimG

    • #65037
      mkell755
      Participant

      Hi Sarah, very nice! You have a nice light voice that is friendly and easy to listen to. I would suggest trying it with a bit more excitement and enthusiasm, like you are telling a friend about this really cool great new thing that she really needs to know about!! It sounds nice but not persuasive enough. Good job on this!

      Mary

    • #65022
      SuperLuke
      Participant

      I think it was a good performance, Sarah. You have a great voice. It sounded more like a cold read. But I think you are trying to advertise Masterclass, right? If so, maybe try to sound more upbeat, the “wow” factor, “all the amazing things you can achieve once you click here to sign up now”.

    • #64979
      artyom123
      Participant

      I love your clarity and humble sounding voice that is kind welcoming. I think this read need more of an amazement factor tailored with a solution. Pretend telling someone that you just came across an amazing new discovery and proceed with the read.

  • #64963
    eglover177
    Participant

    Ok I have taken three shots at this and this is what i settled for any critism is appreciated

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #64980
      artyom123
      Participant

      I think it sounds great in the low register, very authoritative. What can be added is to make it more conversational. try a lead in… like your trying to help a friend get over a hurdle and you have the perfect solution which is Advil. I hope this helps

    • #64975
      sarahtranchina
      Participant

      Hey eglover! Wow wow wow what a voice! I agree with Shmuel that it just felt a little trippy over some words. You may deal with this from time to time because you have that beautiful lower register where it’s sometimes more work to pump those words out clearly so I’d definitely slow down the pace a touch to get them all. You’re awesome!

    • #64967
      Shmuel
      Participant

      Hi eg, right at the beginning, I thought I was listening to a national radio ad. Very good. One tweak i would consider, from sec. 18 to about 22 you sound slightly like you are rushing it, and kind of tripping over the words. The effect is very slight, and I think I only hear it because I was listening very closely. YMMV.

      • #65023
        SuperLuke
        Participant

        You have a great voice in the performance. Maybe sound more relaxed, like you just took an advil that cured your headache, and you might try to sound hurt at first and cured on cue after taking the pill. You sounded super fast towards the end too, which made my attention drift. But all in all, I liked the radio guy type commercial I was hearing

  • #64956
    jmtarleton
    Participant

    Hello everyone, here’s a little more commercial homework. Please share any feedback you may have!

    Many many thanks,

    John

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #64981
      artyom123
      Participant

      great work – diction and clarity. for practice, try reading in a very conversational tone

    • #64974
      sarahtranchina
      Participant

      Hey John! So I had an issue with this as well which is why I’m now hyper focused on it… you have a bit of an echo on all three clips. I played around a bit and found that laying a towel over top of my desk (where my set up is) while I record eats up some of that extra space. Hope this helps!

    • #64960
      eglover177
      Participant

      jmtarleton your last copy sounds gret its the 1st 2 that sound rather flat

  • #64938
    burdahgirl
    Participant

    Thanks for any feedback!

    Habitat For Humanity
    Script:
    Every 7 minutes around the world, Habitat for Humanity serves a family in need of decent housing. Affordable housing solutions might differ from place to place, but to the families who dream of them, help build them and eventually inhabit them, they all add up to just one thing. Home.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #64982
      artyom123
      Participant

      I agree, very clear articulation and pleasant smooth voice. What this could use more of is a deep emotional connection like your empathizing with someone.

    • #64973
      sarahtranchina
      Participant

      Hey burdahgirl! You have a nice crisp and clear voice. Your mic sounds great as well. I thought this was really lovely, you emphasized important words that kept us following along, and made smart choices. Awesome!

    • #64961
      eglover177
      Participant

      Burdahgirl I see your takin this very seriously great sound and clarity

    • #64948
      Robert Broussard
      Participant

      That was really good. Your voice is very easy to listen to. Tone and pacing were very good. I do agree with MDmcghee about the last part but overall very good read!!

    • #64946
      Mdmcghee34
      Participant

      very warm and inviting; great tone for this script; I would suggest a little more pausing before saying “they all add up to just one thing. Home.”

  • #64917
    Bil-Bo
    Participant

    Del Monte

    My granddad built this farm way back in the late 1800s. He had a policy of producing only the finest quality fruits and vegetables. That’s why people began to know and enjoy the name Del Monte. … Well, today, the farm is mine — and ya’ know, I still carry on the proud tradition of only the finest fruits and vegetables. DEL MONTE — only the finest.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #65685
      Jorjecat09
      Participant

      Excellent read! Felt easy going with the right amount of energy without over doing it. Your tone of voice feels like a great big comfortable sweater. Fantastic job!

    • #64972
      sarahtranchina
      Participant

      Hey Bil-Bo. Well this is just excellent from top to bottom. I also hear the static throughout which is the only thing. Remove that and you’re selling a LOT of Del Monte product 🙂

    • #64969
      Dante M.
      Participant

      Good read with nice pacing, but more importantly, there’s some fizz going on every time you speak and unfortunately it’s relatively noticeable. Hopefully you can fix that.

    • #64949
      Robert Broussard
      Participant

      Awesome job Bil-Bo!!

      • #64962
        eglover177
        Participant

        Bill BO WOW THE 1st three words did it for me….You are definitely valuable Great read

    • #64940
      burdahgirl
      Participant

      Oh man, it’s so good! I now have an understanding of what my coach is always saying about creating connection – you nailed it!

    • #64937
      Mdmcghee34
      Participant

      what a great read. cool and relaxing and makes me want to eat some fruits and vegetables. Sound caring and proud to own the Del monte farm. great tone for the script.

    • #64922
      Chad4674
      Participant

      Hi Bil-BO!
      Great read! Very relaxed and tone was consistent throughout the read.

  • #64902
    Jbach
    Participant

    This one is a political spot. Its not my worldview; just challenging myself. Any feedback would be welcome.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #64943
      Mdmcghee34
      Participant

      Good read. I suggest maybe a little more passion or energy could be heard for the candidate and for the state Kentucky and to really hit those money words: our Kentucky values….strong…fight..Rand Paul..destroy our liberty…spend too much

    • #64942
      burdahgirl
      Participant

      Hi Jbach! I think it’s a good read, really clear and good pacing. I would suggest playing around with a little more pitch variance in there to keep it from being too stagnant? I hope that’s helpful!

Viewing 3,171 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.