Feedback Forum

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #15468
    David Goldberg
    Edge Studio Staff

    Hi! Upload your recordings, and get feedback from your peers!

Viewing 3,181 reply threads
  • Author
    Replies
  • #73891
    raymazebarnes
    Participant

    Good evening,

    This is my first time posting to the forum. Looking for critiques on my two reads attached for my enunciation and pacing. Thank you in advance.

    Raymaze Barnes

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #73956
      Jenconnelly20
      Participant

      You have a beautiful strong and clear voice. I would suggest maybe looking at punctuation and where to take breaths to carry a full sentence and idea (I’m working on this too 🙂 Good work!

      • #74205
        raymazebarnes
        Participant

        Thank you Jen and yes I will work on the breaths and punctuation

  • #73884
    RBenesVO
    Participant

    Good Evening,
    Any feedback would be appreciated after making a few tweaks.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #73921
      Provocaleric
      Participant

      You have a clear, young and authoritative sound. I agree with some of the other postings that some of this stuff can seem dry. If I had to criticize anything it would be to give more brightness to your tone and imagine teaching a subject one on one with a student. Otherwise, I liked it!

      • #73934
        RBenesVO
        Participant

        Thank you very much. I agree on the area needing improvement.

    • #73916
      Andres
      Participant

      Really good reads! In each of them you have genuinely smooth even pacing. You speak clearly and it’s easy to understand what you’re saying. I would maybe suggest giving a little more energy to keep your audience interested, informational pieces can sometimes come across as a little dry.

      • #73933
        RBenesVO
        Participant

        Thank you. Adding the energy is something I’m working on. Really appreciate it.

  • #73873
    Kim_Lomax
    Participant

    Hello all! I am brand new to this forum. I started with Edge webinars this month and just had my first coaching session with James Andrews (great!). I have invested time in crafting my home studio space and welcome any feedback about the recording quality in addition to the read. Thank you for your time and consideration! Here is the copy:

    Nature’s Recyclers – Discovery Kids (sourced from the Edge Script library)

    Did you know that mold and bacteria and higher level organisms like beetles, centipedes and, of course, earthworms are all busy recyclers? By breaking down organic matter – stuff like dead plants, p**p, and decaying animals – they create valuable nutrients necessary for rich and fertile soil. Take it from me, a worm who know, we are doing you a big favor.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #73962
      Tracy
      Participant

      This was a fun read. You maintained good energy throughout which is especially important in a children’s reading. On my end the P in p**p came across slightly hard-sounding. There were also some audible breaths at the very beginning and a few times throughout including right before “take it from me.” Could just be an equipment issue but overall a fun listen.

    • #73930
      Erik B
      Participant

      Hi Kim,

      I really liked your read. Your tone and energy are great. The only thing I noticed are, watch out for glottals. I noticed one in the first sentence “bacteria and”, but overall good job.

    • #73922
      Provocaleric
      Participant

      You have a neat voice for creatures, hehe. Your read was clear, friendly and with a nice bright tone. If I had to make a critical remark, I would say to not over emphasize big favor at the end. Your awesome!

    • #73917
      Andres
      Participant

      Fantastic job! I could truly hear you smiling through your words. You were clear and easy to understand, from one beginner to another keep up the good work!

    • #73888
      RBenesVO
      Participant

      Your voice was great for this. Lots of energy, changing in pitch and tone seemed to be in the right spots. I’m listening on my mobile but couldn’t pick up any background noises or over the top breathes.

  • #73869
    bevy
    Participant

    Good Day,

    I would appreciate your feedback on my final narration training assignment. I have been working on eliminating glottal noise. Any other suggestions on improving are also welcome. Thank you!

    Scripts:

    Relaxation:

    To begin, make yourself comfortable, it’s best to lie on your back. Put your arms by your sides not touching your body. Put your feet slightly apart. With each exhalation let all the tension out of your body. Let the tension just dissolve and flow out.

    American Airlines:

    Welcome aboard American Airlines coast-to-coast service. We’ll be happy to do everything possible to make your flight with us a most pleasurable experience. We’ll provide you with all the information you need to know about your flight, your destination, and the equipment on which you are currently flying. In addition, we are proud to present our American Airlines feature film presentation, for our transcontinental passengers. We’d like you now to remove the plastic insert found directly in front of you in the seat back pocket. Please review the safety information during the flight for your own protection, in the unlikely event of an in-flight emergency.

    Real Estate:

    Would you like to buy a house?
    Maybe it’s your first house, or even your second and you just think that MAYBE you didn’t think hard enough about the last one.
    Listen, I love real estate. And in most cases, even a bad deal can work to your advantage in the very long run. But there are dumb things that people do without realizing it when they buy a house.
    Humor me for a short story before we get into the meat of this video.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #73924
      Provocaleric
      Participant

      Bevy,
      You have a pleasant, friendly sound! Your recording sounded a bit loud, perhaps the gain or compression was a bit hot, but I especially liked your American Airlines read

      • #74040
        bevy
        Participant

        Thank you so much for the feedback! I will look into my equipment and adjust the sound.

  • #73823
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    good

  • #73803
    Bil-Bo
    Participant

    Earthbound Farm

    Here at Earthbound Farm, we don’t use any harmful chemical pesticides. All of our organic salads, fruits and vegetables are grown in harmony with nature. And while farming organically may cost more, we think you’ll find Earthbound Farm organic produce is an infinitely better value. Because with each crisp, delicious bite, you can take comfort in knowing you’re protecting your family’s health. Now and for years to come. Earthbound Farm. Food to live by.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #73925
      Provocaleric
      Participant

      A great natural sounding read! The only thing is the recording sounded a bit loud. Good Job!

    • #73850
      JustJohn
      Participant

      Sounds like a keeper to me.

  • #73797
    DillonP
    Participant

    Here is some recordings this week, please give me your thoughts.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #73927
      Provocaleric
      Participant

      Hey Dillon,
      I loved your enthusiasm on the Dominos ad and the political spot, your voice sounds wellsuited for these spots, however I’m hearing too much room reflection and clicks in your mic. Izotopes Voice denoiser is awesome!

      • #73997
        DillonP
        Participant

        Thanks for the input I’ll make sure to remember that and improve more.

  • #73765
    HillOKeefe
    Participant

    Hello everyone! I’d much appreciate a critique of this audition for performance and audio quality. No slate was requested and I thought this one take covered everything my gut told me to go with. I haven’t been practicing as much as I should so be honest – it’ll light a fire under my b**t. Thanks!

    • #73768
      HillOKeefe
      Participant

      Whoops! Acceptable file now attached.

      Attachments:
      You must be logged in to view attached files.
      • #73926
        Provocaleric
        Participant

        You have a nice clear sounding voice. You sound trustworthy and local. The only thing I can think of to critique would be to get even more connected to your copy by giving a adding a little more dynamics with your tone. I love those Wells Fargo ads, so emotional.

  • #73744
    Watson
    Participant

    Hi, everyone ~

    First time poster, but I would love to have some feedback on my two reads below. Thank you in advance. 🙂

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #73764
      HillOKeefe
      Participant

      Hi Watson! I LUV these! Your energy and take on both is spot on for what I imagine is a Gen Z target audience. My only critique is some audible breaths and room noise in the first file. Other than that, you nailed both.

  • #73728
    carynbell
    Participant

    REPOST WITH SCRIPTS:

    BOYS & GIRLS CLUB

    PUT THIS CARD IN THE HANDS OF A CHILD AND THERE’LL BE NO ROOM FOR A GUN. A NEEDLE. OR A KNIFE. IT’S ONLY A PIECE OF PAPER, BUT THAT LITTLE MEMBERSHIP CARD HAS HELPED KEEP MILLIONS OF KIDS OFF DRUGS, OUT OF GANGS AND IN SCHOOL. TO LEARN HOW YOU CAN HELP THE BOYS & GIRLS CLUBS, CALL 1-800-854-CLUB. BOYS & GIRLS CLUBS OF AMERICA. THE POSITIVE PLACE FOR KIDS.

    GEICO

    THESE DAYS, IT SEEMS AS IF EVERY CAR INSURANCE COMPANY NEEDS A SYMBOL. THINGS LIKE A BLANKET OR A HAND. WELL, IF GEICO HAD A SYMBOL, IT WOULD SURELY BE THE FRONTAL LOBE OF THE CEREBRAL CORTEX. YOU SEE…IT’S HERE, DEEP WITHIN THE BRAIN, THAT NERVE IMPULSES FIGURE OUT, “HEY…IT’S SMARTER TO BUY CAR INSURANCE FROM GEICO.” OVER 10,000 DRIVERS SWITCH EACH WEEK! SO CALL FOR A FREE RATE QUOTE TODAY. YEP, THE BRAIN’S A GREAT SYMBOL. WE JUST CAN’T IMAGINE THE MEDULLA OBLONGATA ON OUR STATIONARY. CALL 1-800-4-GEICO. GEICO DIRECT, THE SENSIBLE ALTERNATIVE. NOT AVAILABLE IN
    NEW JERSEY OR MASSACHUSETTS.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #73784
      Under1VO
      Participant

      Hi Carynbell, really fun reads- I like your voice and I believe you have talent! I’d suggest working a little on mic technique- try backing away from the mic just an inch or two and speaking off-axis a little bit and see how that sounds. That should help reduce some of the distortion and plosives. The only other thing that stands out is around halfway through your Geico read the recoding seems to get louder, like it’s a part where you cut two different takes together. Again though, really good reads!

Viewing 3,181 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.