Feedback Forum

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #15468
    David Goldberg
    Edge Studio Staff

    Hi! Upload your recordings, and get feedback from your peers!

Viewing 3,171 reply threads
  • Author
    Replies
  • #76488
    carynbell
    Participant

    Hi All,

    Been working on my pacing and diction. Feedback is appreciated.

    Thanks!

    BENZ 2020 E-CLASS

    A car that can actually see like a human.
    Using stereoscopic cameras and even stopping itself if it has to.
    The technology may be hard to imagine — but why you would want it, is not.
    The 2020 E-class.
    It doesn’t just see the future…
    It is the future.

    USPS PSA

    The US Postal Service wants 2 remind everyone this year 2 protect themselves from becoming victims of identity theft. Promptly remove incoming mail from your mailbox – and don’t give out passwords, pin numbers, or account numbers. 2 learn more, visit consumer.gov/ncpw

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #76513
      Nik
      Participant

      Hi really soothing voice!! I agree with the other comment that it could be a bit faster.

  • #76479
    carynbell
    Participant

    Hi All,

    Been working on my pacing and diction. Feedback is appreciated.

    Thanks!

    BENZ 2020 E-CLASS

    A car that can actually see like a human.
    Using stereoscopic cameras and even stopping itself if it has to.
    The technology may be hard to imagine — but why you would want it, is not.
    The 2020 E-class.
    It doesn’t just see the future…
    It is the future.

    USPS PSA

    The US Postal Service wants 2 remind everyone this year 2 protect themselves from becoming victims of identity theft. Promptly remove incoming mail from your mailbox – and don’t give out passwords, pin numbers, or account numbers. 2 learn more, visit consumer.gov/ncpw

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #76492
      Gill
      Participant

      Caryn, your voice is very soothing. I agree with Joel’s comments on your diction, but wanted to add that it sounds like you sort of have an accent when you say “themselves” like selves drags on maybe southern so i would be aware of that if you’re trying to stay neutral.
      Your pace could slightly be a little faster

      • This reply was modified 2 years, 7 months ago by Gill.
      • This reply was modified 2 years, 7 months ago by Gill.
    • #76482
      Joel
      Participant

      Cary, very listenable voice. I would take a look at your diction for words like “promptly” and when you say, “to learn more.” You said, “t’ learn more.” Your focus on using clear diction at “vist consumer.gov/ncpw” was good. My coach noted that instead of saying “your,” I was say, “yer.” So I think we all sometimes shorten some words in our day to day language use. But for voice over work we have to more careful. Also, you only uploaded one mp3 file. I liked your pacing.

      • #76487
        carynbell
        Participant

        Thanks Joel!!! I’ll fix that other file.

  • #76463
    rustylj63
    Participant

    Only one read tonight… thank you, in advance for your feedback. It is really helping.

    Please disregard the audio quality, I’m sitting at my desk instead of in my “studio.”

    Thank you!

    Rusty

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #76503
      indexasp
      Participant

      I’d make that opening question stronger and more confident.. have more of a POV! 🙂 And reduce the silence after the question by just a beat – it stretches out a beat too long imho.

      Listenable voice for sure..

    • #76475
      TimberTykes
      Participant

      I want to say thay you have a great voice! Especially for this read. If I had any feedback, I think you could work on the enhancement of your words between commas, and as for the opening line to this script, I felt like there was hesitation when asking the question, leaving the line feeling a little awkward. Other than that, a great read!

      • This reply was modified 2 years, 7 months ago by TimberTykes.
  • #76448
    ashleymitchel
    Participant

    Practicing for my narration demo – any feedback is appreciated!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #76709
      chloeblackstone
      Participant

      Hi Ashley! I liked your reads, both sound natural. My note for you on Primanti Bros one, I’m noticing each sentence seems to end on the same pitch. Maybe you could try varying the tone / pitch of the last word of each sentence, to keep the listener engaged.

    • #76460
      rustylj63
      Participant

      Hi Ashley,

      Thanks for the feedback on my Allure read. I listened to both of yours and feel you did a really good job, especially with the Bob Ross one. One note I had on the Primanti brothers is about timing… I might put a small pause, maybe another heartbeat, between “…strip district” and “an area.” Try it and let me know what you think… I felt like they were both good reads!

      • #76469
        ashleymitchel
        Participant

        Hi Rusty! Great feedback, thank you. I’ll give the small pause a try.

    • #76451
      mikemcgann
      Participant

      Bob Ross was pretty good to me, just watch for plosives and background shuffling. I may suggest to inflect up a little more at the question at the end.

      Primanti Bros was pretty good, but you may want to slow down a little bit on the reading to enforce the idea of nostalgia in the story telling and allow a beat between sentences as well.

      Overall, I thought both were done well.

      • #76470
        ashleymitchel
        Participant

        Thank you for the feedback! Very helpful. I often get the “slow down” note 😛

  • #76444
    Katerina
    Participant

    Buy handicrafts online at The Bombay Store. Our products showcase a perfect blend of art and tradition with a contemporary touch. The broad categories that we deal in are: Artefacts, Home Décor, Souvenirs, Gifts, Pashmina’s and Fashion Accessories. Visit: https://thebombaystore.com

  • #76433
    rustylj63
    Participant

    Hey Everyone,

    Sooo… Same drill as my last posting. I’ve got two recordings… same read. Hoping for feedback on the read, but also which voice is preferred.

    Thanks!

    Rusty

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #76452
      mikemcgann
      Participant

      Nice job on the reads as well as eliminating more background noise since the other samples.

      I would just suggest to either lower your gain a little or make a little more distance on the mic, not by much though, as you’re doing well isolating your voice in the room. It seems like it’s picking up some nasal pops, just between the 17 to 20 sec on allure 1.
      I used to get these a lot more often, but if you lower your head just a little more you may find it will reduce the appearance of them. I think of it like treading water with your head on the surface, you realize how much air makes it out your nose and creates pops.

      Besides that, you did great matching the voice to the feel of the scripts.

      • #76462
        rustylj63
        Participant

        Mike,

        I continue to appreciate the detailed feedback. I am really learning to hate nasal pops. I contracted pneumonia back in October and haven’t been able to shake all the congestion yet. I HATE it!

        • #76467
          mikemcgann
          Participant

          Yeah, those nasal pops are a pain. They can even make you sound stuffed up when you’re not! I was dumbfounded where the pops were coming from in my recordings early on until I stumbled upon it. A little head tilt down and speaking from the diaphragm made a big difference. Hope you feel better.

    • #76445
      ashleymitchel
      Participant

      I love Allure 1! So smooth. I like how you take your time to savor each phrase.

  • #76431
    chloeblackstone
    Participant

    Hi Folks! I would love some feedback on this B****r documentary take. Things I’m working on are diction, and pitching down consistently at the end of sentences. Any input is welcome! Thanks. – Chloe

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #76495
      Gill
      Participant

      Chole, your read is really engaging, I wanted to hear more. I think you did a great job changing your flow.

      • This reply was modified 2 years, 7 months ago by Gill.
    • #76446
      ashleymitchel
      Participant

      Your annunciation is on point!

  • #76421
    touzet
    Participant

    Here’s a spot for Chevy Truck Month.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #76447
      ashleymitchel
      Participant

      Wow, sounds like it’s ready for the radio! The word “boulder” and “month” were slightly garbled but it sounded more like a recording issue than a pronunciation issue.

    • #76436
      rustylj63
      Participant

      hello, your recording sounded great! Strong voice, good tempo, good pitch variation. The only thing I could make note on is that the word “Bolder” wasn’t very clear to me. Otherwise, really good job in my opinion!

  • #76413
    rustylj63
    Participant

    Hey Folks, I’ve got a couple of files I’m posting. They are the same read, but different voices. Could I please not only get feedback on how the read went, but also, which voice is preferred?

    Thank you so much!

    Rusty

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #76427
      Wltrcurtis
      Participant

      Hi, I went through both reads a couple times. The first read has more energy in it. I did notice some plosives during the read. The second read was much clearer but could use some energy. They both have some general background noise but that can be edited out. In terms of preference, I think I would enjoy hearing the second reading more. Its a deeper voice voice with more clarity. Maybe you could try different tone or changing tempo. Hope this helped.

  • #76411
    Wltrcurtis
    Participant

    Hi Everyone, looking for feedback on another read. All advice and tips are welcome. Really appreciate specific feedback. Thanks in advance.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #76416
      rustylj63
      Participant

      Hey Man, is it Walter or Curtis? Which do you prefer?

      I liked your voice, tempo, and changes in tone… but to me it did sound chunky, like you were reading independent clauses.

      • #76428
        Wltrcurtis
        Participant

        Hi, either is fine. Appreciate the feedback. I went to listen to it again later in the night. You’re right about the chunky sound. I think I edited my audio too much and it gave it a weird sound.

Viewing 3,171 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.