Feedback Forum

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #15468
    David Goldberg
    Edge Studio Staff

    Hi! Upload your recordings, and get feedback from your peers!

Viewing 3,169 reply threads
  • Author
    Replies
  • #92350
    Mike Koziol
    Participant

    Hi,

    Let’s try this again.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #92608
      Emily Gauthier
      Participant

      Hi Mike!

      Welcome to the edge forum! Hope we can help you give tips and advice to better your voice! It’s nice to have you.

      You have a very knowledgeable-sounding voice, which I think lends itself nicely to this piece. However, a lot of your tone stays in the same range, making it more noticeable that you’re reading a piece. I would start with trying to give slight adjustments to your tone by envisioning telling this to someone. When you ask the question, try to think of a memory when you were in a frustrated position, asking yourself “how do I get out of this?” and when you reveal to the listener the solution, remember that relief of when you finally had your problem solved.

      I hope this helps!

    • #92355
      Jillian Sclafani
      Participant

      What a great voice!! I would say to maybe work on your diction as some of the words get a little lost, and pause a little less between words within sentences so there is a better flow. Other than that, you sound awesome!

  • #92345
    Mike Koziol
    Participant

    Hi all,

    New to the forum and my first submission. Look forward to any and all feedback. Thanks

  • #92326
    Earthbul
    Participant

    Another recording from the backseat. Getting a at875r shotgun for Christmas. Looking forward to trying it out. Anyone else use this particular mic ?

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #92356
      Jillian Sclafani
      Participant

      You absolutely cannot tell that this was recorded in a car. You sound fantastic! Keep up the awesome work!

  • #92318
    Earthbul
    Participant

    First time recording a spot in my car. Due to issues at the moment in treating my space I had to resort to extreme measures lol let me know what you think of the quality. Any and all comments welcomed.
    Ps has anyone else here resorted to recording in unexpected places ?

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #92647
      alayne_chappell
      Participant

      Haha, I have definitely recorded in my car too. Those of us with a noisy home have to get creative 🙂 I think this read sounds great. The pace is on point and the tone feels very authentic and fits the subject matter well. I’ve been really trying to achieve that conversational tone and you’re nailing it!

  • #92194
    Emily Gauthier
    Participant

    Hello again everyone!

    I’ve been trying to get better at slowing down on the customer name, so let me know if I was able to do that (especially with crayola!). Thank you for all the feedback you’ve given so far!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #92357
      Jillian Sclafani
      Participant

      Based off these recordings, I would buy from either company lol! Crayola is clearly pronounced and slow enough that it hits the beat. Awesome job!

    • #92245
      Kumpenny
      Participant

      Yes, the brand name is clearly audible.

  • #92159
    ierxyzz
    Participant

    Hi all, this is a commercial copy read for Trendi.com. Thanks in advance for any feedback!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #92182
      AanTourism
      Participant

      Your audio quality is excellent, and your confidence in the read is commendable. I suggest incorporating more smiles, especially from the line “great style…” to infuse enthusiasm throughout the wrap-up. Consider channeling a situation or thought that brings you joy for a more upbeat tone. I appreciate the natural and down-to-earth delivery, avoiding any forced elements.

      • This reply was modified 11 months, 3 weeks ago by AanTourism.
      • This reply was modified 11 months, 3 weeks ago by AanTourism.
    • #92175
      Grace17
      Participant

      Your audio quality seems really good, and you have great confidence in the read. I advice smiling more from the line “great style,…” It’ll be good to see more enthusiasm from that line onward as wrap up the read. Perhaps think about a situation or thing that makes you very happy. I also like that you don’t push. The read is very casual and down-to-earth which is nice.

  • #92155
    Grace17
    Participant

    I would love technique feedback on this. Thank you!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #92197
      Emily Gauthier
      Participant

      Hi Grace!

      I’m not sure if my feedback is technique-related, but I hope this helps! I’m not sure if you edited your audio but the sentences come one after another a little too fast so it sounds like one big sentence. I would also try to envision the food or something that makes your mouth water as you’re talking about the ingredients, as right now there’s not much variation so it sounds tonally samey.

      Nice work though!

  • #91948
    mikemcgann
    Participant

    Hello, everyone.

    Here are two commercial PSAs for feedback.

    Thanks.

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #92174
      Grace17
      Participant

      wow, you have a really nice resonant voice. It seems to me like you have experience doing announcer types of reads. The announcer voice is great when it’s called for. Regarding the “I am anxiety,” i advice not doing the announcer voice, and allowing your voice to show the range of emotions depicted in the script. You should also try to make the two characters sound different, when they sound the same I think it takes the audience out of the “suspension of disbelief” making them very aware that this is a commercial. Doing something, like changing your pitch, tone or pace allows the listener to be immersed in the very interesting story you’re telling. I belief the narrator who says the website and phone number at the end should also have a distinct difference in their voice to distinguish them from the characters. It may be helpful to also think about “why” you’re saying each line, so you can better connect with it’s significance and identify an appropriate emotion to show.

      For the cancer society read, though you have a great sounding voice and the pacing seems good to me, it would be nice to have more emotion in your read so you sound more like a real person who actually cares about what you’re saying rather than a more or less indifferent narrator. I advice visualizing a person or situation that will elicit empathy for the very deep, personal problems you speak about in your two reads. For example, visualizing someone you care deeply about suffering from anxiety or some ailment, or a situation in which you’re informing someone of an issue you care about regardless of what that is.

  • #91940
    Stephen Winburn
    Participant

    Hello again friends!

    We’re narrowing down scripts for my reel and this is one I like so I’ve provided 3 reads. I was playing with different tones for each read so as a general note choosing which of the 3 you prefer is helpful! For more specific notes i was asked to focus on being conversational, having a specific audience in mind, and avoiding micro pauses: any specific notes on those 3 things would also be much appreciated!

    I apologize in advance for the shoddy microphone!
    -Steph

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #91944
      Declan Waters
      Participant

      Hi Steph – nice reads! Some notes:
      1. I like the tone of your first take the best – it’s the most casual and laid back ie conversational, in my mind.
      2. I like the speed of #2, and the passion of #3, but I think overall you achieve conversational tone, audience specification, and lack of micro pauses best in #1.
      3. To nitpick, there is a micropause before the word “happier” in #1 that disrupts the flow a little bit, I think.
      4. (Referring to #1) Your diction overall is great, though I noticed the word “and” (something I struggle with, so I notice it in particular in other people’s reads) sounds like “an” without the D at the end of the word to round it out.

      I hope this helps!
      Dec

  • #91882
    Declan Waters
    Participant

    Hello!

    I am starting up my VO business, and would love feedback, including technical. How’s my sound, anything to improve that you notice? I want to make sure my studio space is up to par. Feel free to be blunt/direct (but helpful), please. Thanks!

    Attachments:
    You must be logged in to view attached files.
    • #91953
      Angela Doyle
      Participant

      DAFC–it felt like you weren’t into it nearly as much as for Retail Explainer. I liked the energy in the latter. I felt like you connected more with the copy in DAFC as you went along, but the first couple of lines didn’t grab me very much.

      I like your voice.

    • #91936
      Earthbul
      Participant

      The first read could have been read with a little more smile. I also felt the second read was just a little too monotone. I’m just nitpicking though. The reads are really solid overall. Your voice and diction are awesome and your recording quality is aces.

Viewing 3,169 reply threads
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.